November 26th, 2020, 10:31 PM
I think these past two games might be my best yet. Finally getting better lol. Only took two years.
November 26th, 2020, 10:11 PM
November 26th, 2020, 01:31 AM
I'm prob not going to be here most of today due it being Thanksgiving so don't expect me here for more than a few minutes at a time.
November 25th, 2020, 07:46 PM

Originally Posted by
Astil
1606345168
(
#1598)

Originally Posted by
lukess1
1606344828
(
#1597)

Originally Posted by
Astil
1606343754
(
#1596)
Is there a chance of a second team?
I doubt there's two teams and a cult
Yeah me too but that hint sounds like red team down, no?
Could it be just cult left? Maybe an SK?
November 25th, 2020, 06:53 PM

Originally Posted by
Astil
1606343754
(
#1596)
Is there a chance of a second team?
I doubt there's two teams and a cult
November 25th, 2020, 04:33 PM

Originally Posted by
zergon
1606332669
(
#1582)
It sure is quiet in here. I know you think you found a wolf but I can promise you that the game won´t end when I´m lynched so hoping a bit more activity.
Was this a slip? You did t say part of the caravan. You just said not wolf and that’s shady when there’s a 3p
November 25th, 2020, 12:36 PM

Originally Posted by
zergon
1606321493
(
#1564)

Originally Posted by
lukess1
1606320920
(
#1562)
Hey Batman: I was the reason for the tah lynch lol. Also: I don’t believe zergon. ##Vote zergon
Out of interest, what made you check Tak night 1? Mainly just curious as I was sure he was counter wagon to Pugs.
I felt he was scummy
November 25th, 2020, 12:36 PM

Originally Posted by
BATMAN
1606321987
(
#1565)

Originally Posted by
lukess1
1606320920
(
#1562)
Hey Batman: I was the reason for the tah lynch lol. Also: I don’t believe zergon. ##Vote zergon
I didn’t believe your check. I gave a better reason and proof than you did why she was scum. And I pushed her the day before. So yeah people believed your check I guess but that was kinda weak if you asked me. I made my own case Teo days in a row and showed why scum killed in there and yeah I don’t believe zergon at all.
He’s outed.
##Vote zergon
I would vote you rn if it wasn’t for my check. There is no better reason than a red check.
November 25th, 2020, 12:15 PM
Hey Batman: I was the reason for the tah lynch lol. Also: I don’t believe zergon. ##Vote zergon
November 24th, 2020, 11:56 PM

Originally Posted by
Astil
1606276550
(
#1493)

Originally Posted by
lukess1
1606276524
(
#1491)
No one's mentioned this, but I think MLT's faction might be a cult.
I mentioned it

My bad.
November 24th, 2020, 11:55 PM
No one's mentioned this, but I think MLT's faction might be a cult.
November 24th, 2020, 11:42 PM

Originally Posted by
markisprettyok
1606275163
(
#1481)

Originally Posted by
lukess1
1606274753
(
#1473)

Originally Posted by
Astil
1606274715
(
#1472)

Originally Posted by
lukess1
1606274622
(
#1469)
##Unvote BATMANI just got my PM and I believe Batman is town.
Nice. Glad to be wrong.Just to put it to bed, any chance of it being godfather?
I’d guess.
Didn't you say your results could be wrong. Also, I'm going to need @
zergon to tell me what he's been up to.
My role has a good chance of being right.
November 24th, 2020, 11:28 PM

Originally Posted by
Astil
1606274884
(
#1475)

Originally Posted by
lukess1
1606274753
(
#1473)

Originally Posted by
Astil
1606274715
(
#1472)

Originally Posted by
lukess1
1606274622
(
#1469)
##Unvote BATMAN
I just got my PM and I believe Batman is town.
Nice. Glad to be wrong.
Just to put it to bed, any chance of it being godfather?
I’d guess.
You'd guess yes?
You'd guess no?
I guess it’s a possibility
November 24th, 2020, 11:25 PM

Originally Posted by
Astil
1606274715
(
#1472)

Originally Posted by
lukess1
1606274622
(
#1469)
##Unvote BATMAN
I just got my PM and I believe Batman is town.
Nice. Glad to be wrong.
Just to put it to bed, any chance of it being godfather?
I’d guess.
November 24th, 2020, 11:23 PM
##Unvote BATMAN
I just got my PM and I believe Batman is town.
November 24th, 2020, 11:15 PM
##Vote BATMAN
I'm fine with this for now.
November 24th, 2020, 11:14 PM

Originally Posted by
markisprettyok
1606273999
(
#1454)

Originally Posted by
Astil
1606273604
(
#1449)

Originally Posted by
markisprettyok
1606273552
(
#1448)

Originally Posted by
Ace Marvel
1606270911
(
#1438)
I lied I can kill every odd night. I claim the Eternal Phoenix kill. I'm the worst vig sorry.
No way DoubtingThomas is still alive at this point.

Originally Posted by
DoubtingThomas
1606271725
(
#1439)
hmm. i might have been roleblocked
I stole from DT. Feel pretty good about him being town.
Is it possible to both hate and love a play at the same time...
At least we know now, right? Between ignoramus coming up scum and DT being town,I'd say BATMAN is the early favorite this phase.
I copped Batman but didn't get a PM.
November 24th, 2020, 10:58 PM

Originally Posted by
Astil
1606272779
(
#1445)
##Vote BATMAN
Tucks in vote, reads it bed time story.
You have info?
November 24th, 2020, 10:43 PM

Originally Posted by
Ace Marvel
1606272104
(
#1442)

Originally Posted by
DoubtingThomas
1606271936
(
#1441)
if I were a scum why would I out that you are my green check? like you believe that I knew you were town smith? why would I - a scum person - who apparently knows what role you are and see you kill people at night not just secretly try to kill you? why would I out that you are my green check so you are lock clear?
And you don't find it strange that the cop is still alive? Did you expect to make it this far?
I'm shocked I'm still alive as someone with a cop aspect.
November 23rd, 2020, 06:01 PM
Completed NVM.

Originally Posted by
lukess1
1606168589
(
#1225)

Originally Posted by
BATMAN
1606167671
(
#1224)
Luke
?
NVM.
November 23rd, 2020, 05:56 PM
Completed ?

Originally Posted by
BATMAN
1606167671
(
#1224)
Luke
?
November 22nd, 2020, 07:35 PM
I’m not super confident about anyone but I think ig is my scummiest lean rn.##Vote ignoramus
November 22nd, 2020, 12:06 PM
I don’t see why people think mark is scum tbh.
November 21st, 2020, 11:25 PM
November 21st, 2020, 11:24 PM

Originally Posted by
BATMAN
1606015242
(
#1012)

Originally Posted by
lukess1
1606014991
(
#1010)

Originally Posted by
Ace Marvel
1606014149
(
#1009)

Originally Posted by
Darr
1606011550
(
#1008)
The night proceeded with no bandits about. Yet still, mischief was afoot. Two more bodies were found, and both were full of stab wounds reminiscent of a sword.
So there you go! both were stabs made by swords, it means mafia can either attack a second time or hit the caravan or last night they hit the protected target.
##Vote markisprettyok
Nah. My night action was to kill someone in a one night vig sort of thing and I murdered Esooa.
Why??
I was so sus of them from defending tah
November 21st, 2020, 11:16 PM

Originally Posted by
Ace Marvel
1606014149
(
#1009)

Originally Posted by
Darr
1606011550
(
#1008)
The night proceeded with no bandits about. Yet still, mischief was afoot. Two more bodies were found, and both were full of stab wounds reminiscent of a sword.
So there you go! both were stabs made by swords, it means mafia can either attack a second time or hit the caravan or last night they hit the protected target.
##Vote markisprettyok
Nah. My night action was to kill someone in a one night vig sort of thing and I murdered Esooa.
November 20th, 2020, 04:46 AM
Completed Yes.

Originally Posted by
Eliphas
1605860963
(
#942)

Originally Posted by
lukess1
1605805020
(
#845)

Originally Posted by
Ace Marvel
1605804764
(
#843)
Am I the only one that clearly sees that Batman is not town?
I think esooa is scummier.

Originally Posted by
markisprettyok
1605805086
(
#846)

Originally Posted by
lukess1
1605805020
(
#845)

Originally Posted by
Ace Marvel
1605804764
(
#843)
Am I the only one that clearly sees that Batman is not town?
I think esooa is scummier.
Agreed.
Because of the talk on Takhitty?
Yes.
November 20th, 2020, 04:10 AM
Completed Yes.

Originally Posted by
Eliphas
1605859552
(
#932)

Originally Posted by
Esooa
1605752327
(
#624)
@
lukess1 What do you think of BATMAN? Why do you think Tahkitty became the counter wagon so randomly when a mafia was the main vote? Why do you think two Tahkitty voters were killed?
Wasn't Pugskin the counter wagon to lukess1? And then it turned to Takhitty after Pugskin said what they said?
Yes.
November 20th, 2020, 04:10 AM
Completed no

Originally Posted by
Eliphas
1605859174
(
#929)

Originally Posted by
lukess1
1605751560
(
#608)
##Vote Takhitty
Wyd last night?

Originally Posted by
lukess1
1605751786
(
#610)

Originally Posted by
Esooa
1605751759
(
#609)
you realize voting takhitty is extremely bad, right?
Not when he's a bandit.

Originally Posted by
lukess1
1605751835
(
#613)

Originally Posted by
Esooa
1605751796
(
#612)

Originally Posted by
lukess1
1605751786
(
#610)
Not when he's a bandit.
Explain, then
My result.

Originally Posted by
lukess1
1605751888
(
#616)

Originally Posted by
Esooa
1605751870
(
#615)

Originally Posted by
lukess1
1605751835
(
#613)
My result.
You're claiming cop?
Partly.

Originally Posted by
lukess1
1605752128
(
#619)
To be transparent: there could be a framer and my role says it will come out with good but not perfect accuracy. But I have a feeling they are maf.

Originally Posted by
lukess1
1605752177
(
#622)

Originally Posted by
Esooa
1605752135
(
#620)
well that's interesting. Can you explain your role? Full cop? Why check Tahkitty? That makes the day 1 very strange though lol
I have 5 diff things at random. I picked Tahkitty because I didn't trust them.
I generally think it is advisable to follow the results. I red check is a red check.
@
lukess1 forgive me if you have answered this, but does what you were told give a probability on the the accuracy of the result?
no
November 20th, 2020, 04:10 AM

Originally Posted by
Eliphas
1605859800
(
#933)

Originally Posted by
lukess1
1605754442
(
#657)
@
Esooa Don't worry about Batman if Tak is town.
I don't understand this?
My role isn't just a cop.
November 20th, 2020, 03:05 AM
From catching up, I think Destiny is town and I lean town on Batman and Ace. If tah ends up wolf like my check says, I think Esooa has to be the next lynch just based on how hard of a defense they are doing rn.
November 19th, 2020, 05:01 PM

Originally Posted by
ignoramus
1605819056
(
#861)

Originally Posted by
zergon
1605786682
(
#807)

Originally Posted by
ignoramus
1605783447
(
#806)
P
#803 - does this mean you scum read them? or you're entertaining tinfoil?
If options are wolf read or tinfoil then tinfoil is the answer but here´s bit more specific answer.
There´s a reason for townie to give fake results as well so it doesn´t necessarily mean that they would be wolfs even if they lie their result.
I read Esooa as town and unsure of DoubtingThomas. I do read Ace Marvel (DT´s read) as town with slight reservation though so I´m not overly worried on those claims right now.

Originally Posted by
Ace Marvel
1605804764
(
#843)
Am I the only one that clearly sees that Batman is not town?
..do I need to fix my glasses again?
Because I'm not sure if we're seeing the same thing rn

Originally Posted by
markisprettyok
1605805086
(
#846)

Originally Posted by
lukess1
1605805020
(
#845)

Originally Posted by
Ace Marvel
1605804764
(
#843)
Am I the only one that clearly sees that Batman is not town?
I think esooa is scummier.
Agreed.
?????

Originally Posted by
zergon
1605811543
(
#859)
@
ignoramus, what is your stance on day 1 lynch? Do you prefer to lynch day 1 or do you prefer to never lynch during first day or something in between?
I prefer to not eliminate D1 but I normally don't have much of a say in matters like those.
Esooa is trying real hard to save a red check.
November 19th, 2020, 12:57 PM

Originally Posted by
Ace Marvel
1605804764
(
#843)
Am I the only one that clearly sees that Batman is not town?
I think esooa is scummier.
November 19th, 2020, 12:06 PM

Originally Posted by
Emark
1605801325
(
#832)
OK, crummy work schedule behind me.
@
markisprettyok I hope things stay quiet in your neck of the woods with no virus issues. WA has restarted some of the early restrictions when this thing really took hold.
@
lukess1 If you had to bet all of your chips on your result, would you go all-in or fold? I ask because I will always vote the red check.
I'd prob go all-in
November 19th, 2020, 11:18 AM

Originally Posted by
Astil
1605799061
(
#830)
Also I find the writing in post 1 to be more telling of a cause effect style of attack then scum targeted. It doesn't say bandits may choose to attack the caravan it says the caravan may be attacked by bandits. I'd bet the attacking horde is an NPC
I assume scum has to allocate a group of people just like town, and if town outnumbers scum they don't succeed.
November 19th, 2020, 11:14 AM

Originally Posted by
Ace Marvel
1605798820
(
#827)

Originally Posted by
BATMAN
1605798225
(
#826)
I think wolves tried to attack the wagon and if they do they cannot shot us. I have some similar restrictions
Does that means that the Leion kill was done by a third party?
With how pr heavy this game is, I wouldn't be shocked.
November 19th, 2020, 03:16 AM

Originally Posted by
Ace Marvel
1605770067
(
#789)
Prince could mean leader as in Godfather, with that roll in the game mafia knows there is at least one cop roll.
Letting Pugs live would mean most probably the cop would green check her. So in no universe it is wise for me to hammer that role, specially in a moment I was not even in danger or considered to be voted off.
I could be wrong, but that is what I get from that role, it's pure speculation.
Prince reads to me like they would become godfather if the gf were to end up dying eventually and until then was powerless. I've seen roles like this in games before so it wouldn't surprise me here.
November 19th, 2020, 03:12 AM

Originally Posted by
ignoramus
1605769686
(
#787)

Originally Posted by
lukess1
1605769564
(
#786)

Originally Posted by
ignoramus
1605769516
(
#785)

Originally Posted by
Ace Marvel
1605769397
(
#783)
We are missing the info about the pr, but it sounds important.
Agreed
Mine?
Whuh
I was talking about the Pug flip
Ohhhhhh.
November 19th, 2020, 03:06 AM

Originally Posted by
ignoramus
1605769516
(
#785)

Originally Posted by
Ace Marvel
1605769397
(
#783)
We are missing the info about the pr, but it sounds important.
Agreed
Mine?
November 19th, 2020, 02:21 AM

Originally Posted by
BATMAN
1605766802
(
#772)

Originally Posted by
zergon
1605766509
(
#770)

Originally Posted by
BATMAN
1605764109
(
#759)
Yeah I don’t think ace is cleared.
Same question than for MLT, you don´t believe the green check DoubtingThomas gave then?
I just think he’s not lock clear. I don’t know which is the real check, time will tell. I don’t find ace very wolfy per say. He could be town but I’m not so sure
Yeah. I have an null read on Ace. His tarot card stuff seems weird but towny.
November 19th, 2020, 12:47 AM

Originally Posted by
Ace Marvel
1605761165
(
#729)
##Vote BATMAN
Why are you voting against a check?
November 19th, 2020, 12:39 AM

Originally Posted by
DoubtingThomas
1605760547
(
#713)
what's wrong w tahkitty batman
I got a scum check.
November 18th, 2020, 11:45 PM

Originally Posted by
Astil
1605757404
(
#687)

Originally Posted by
MLT
1605756521
(
#682)

Originally Posted by
lukess1
1605756385
(
#681)
How about we lynch the check? Sounds good to me.
Yes it does, but no harm in talking things out, no?
Townie
There also isn't a majority end so we can get the votes and still talk.
November 18th, 2020, 11:30 PM

Originally Posted by
MLT
1605756521
(
#682)

Originally Posted by
lukess1
1605756385
(
#681)
How about we lynch the check? Sounds good to me.
Yes it does, but no harm in talking things out, no?
Fair. I want to hear more from @Emark today.
November 18th, 2020, 11:26 PM
How about we lynch the check? Sounds good to me.
November 18th, 2020, 11:18 PM
There's no point in talking about this anymore. Let's move on to the living please.
November 18th, 2020, 10:54 PM
@Esooa Don't worry about Batman if Tak is town.
November 18th, 2020, 10:37 PM

Originally Posted by
Esooa
1605753180
(
#637)
Batman, you're either a bad player or mafia. You're actually just coming in here at start of day to insta-vote the counter wagon to a mafia with night kills that make no sense and you're acting like the night kill outright indict Tahkitty without consideration. It's horrid play
There is a red check.
November 18th, 2020, 10:29 PM

Originally Posted by
Esooa
1605752906
(
#633)
Batman's day 1 was atrociously bad, and he started the push on Tahkitty and he also randomly flipped on pug, who was mafia. You said yourself, your check isn't for certain reliable. I think batman is EXTREMELY scummy, and if he dies and is town that makes it much more likely Tahkitty is mafia. In that way, I see it as a sort of 1 for 1. I think, based on the voting and your check, one of them is certainly mafia. I just think Batman is more likely mafia, so I want to kill him first.
There are other ways to deal with Batman if he is scum. You lynch the check.
November 18th, 2020, 10:26 PM

Originally Posted by
Esooa
1605752725
(
#630)
Honestly even with lukess's check I'd rather lynch batman today
Wolf.