Search:

Type: Posts; User: SheepButBad

Page 1 of 60 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.07 seconds.

  1. Postgame#18410

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed I think we had enough defense, with the ITA rate...

    Quote Originally Posted by CrimsonFox (#18409)
    i don't think this was balanced. I think the skaven and the vampires needed a bit more defense and a lot more peeks.
    I think we had enough defense, with the ITA rate decreasing and the doc
  2. Postgame#18395

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed XD

    Quote Originally Posted by Jackofhearts2005 (#18394)
    Quote Originally Posted by gallowsCalibrator (#18319)
    4LSO, J4CK, C4N W3 K33P TH3 SK4V3N 4CCOUNTS?
    @gallowsCalibrator yeah you can have it lol
    XD
  3. Postgame#18372

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed oh that were there any specific anti-claims that...

    Quote Originally Posted by Dale (#18368)
    Quote Originally Posted by SheepButBad (#18365)
    Quote Originally Posted by Dale (#18361)
    Though vamps getting to claim d1 with no repocussions was pretty disgusting.
    It was d2
    and fleur claimed because they were under pressure
    i claimed uhhh because
    Still pretty disgusting when I got Anti-Claim killed and you end games lol
    oh that
    were there any specific anti-claims that could have got us?
  4. Postgame#18369

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed poetry event was very fun

    Quote Originally Posted by TripleHaven (#18355)
    A few host notes, these are sort of disorganized:

    I was very happy with how this setup turned out! For those who don't know, we had a last-second switch from 81 to 60 players, and with a change like that it could have easily gone poorly, but jack & I worked really hard to get everything ironed out so for the most part the setup was well received. There are a few smaller things I wish I would've thought of or asked about before the game started, but nothing that effected the balance of the game negatively. Luckily, Jack ended up the guy with the most knowledge of the setup, so when all else failed I had him to fall back onto. I had never tried running multiball before, but this experience was fun (albeit chaotic at times)!

    I said this in dead chat a little while ago, but the events this game were VERY unplanned, as in "we decided to have events less than 3 days before the game started" unplanned. All of that aside, I'm glad that people seemed to have fun with them.

    The game was very fun to spectate! It constantly went back and forth who DVC thought were going to win, and no alignment really dominated until the very end. Seeing the game switch from wolf-favored to town-favored overnight was exciting. A lot of this game ended up coming down to mechanical play (shoutout to shad for that sick fakeclaim)

    For both of our first mashes, this game really could've been much worse in terms of mod errors. I'm sorry to @lol for the unfortunate sub out. I put him on our action processing spreadsheet as dead and gave him the DVC with his slot still alive, this ended up impacting scum by a lot as lol was a consensus town read and needed to be subbed out.

    Other then that big one, most of the other errors were very minor things which i'm grateful for. We were both sort of expecting- or rather fearing- that something game-breaking would happen but it didn't, luckily!

    I wanna doubly-thank @Jackofhearts2005 for this great experience I didn't know anything about warhammer before deciding to cohost this mash with him but hearing him nerd out about everything about it was fun to watch he's a great host, designer and flavor writer, credit goes out to him! I'm excited to cohost another game with him, whether that be sooner or later.

    On top of that, thank you guys all for playing!
    poetry event was very fun
  5. Postgame#18365

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed It was d2 and fleur claimed because they were...

    Quote Originally Posted by Dale (#18361)
    Though vamps getting to claim d1 with no repocussions was pretty disgusting.
    It was d2
    and fleur claimed because they were under pressure
    i claimed uhhh because
  6. Postgame#18354

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed I'd be absolutely horrid at scumsiding tbh

    Quote Originally Posted by AndrewGreve (#18353)
    Quote Originally Posted by SheepButBad (#18344)
    Quote Originally Posted by AndrewGreve (#18341)
    Quote Originally Posted by Fleur (#18275)
    What is based about somebody not winning who clearly deserved it and was non hostile as they said?
    You didn't play towards your Wincon and lost. It makes perfect sense. The angle shooting cheating play style losing is also nice
    Was there anything involved in "not playing towards your wincon" besides claiming?
    Town siding to hard for too long was the antiwincon part. Claiming is debatable, I didn't read any of it so it might have been necessary

    Batman stuff and not faking a green on a scum or faking a red(that wasn't completely obviously fake) on last day.
    I'd be absolutely horrid at scumsiding tbh
  7. Postgame#18352

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed We could have protected Cider (who we thought was...

    Quote Originally Posted by Kane (#18347)
    Quote Originally Posted by SheepButBad (#18344)
    Quote Originally Posted by AndrewGreve (#18341)
    Quote Originally Posted by Fleur (#18275)
    What is based about somebody not winning who clearly deserved it and was non hostile as they said?
    You didn't play towards your Wincon and lost. It makes perfect sense. The angle shooting cheating play style losing is also nice
    Was there anything involved in "not playing towards your wincon" besides claiming?
    A couple of things mainly that I explained already during the game. When you get this sort of role you need to let the game keep thinning out. You killed to many mafia to realistically get their, and town vigs would have for sure dumped kp into Santy/Cider last night if they didn't shoot at you guys. Unless you had a double role block or something already lined up.
    We could have protected Cider (who we thought was wolf), and blocked the other one if santy didn't die
  8. Postgame#18344

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed Was there anything involved in "not playing...

    Quote Originally Posted by AndrewGreve (#18341)
    Quote Originally Posted by Fleur (#18275)
    What is based about somebody not winning who clearly deserved it and was non hostile as they said?
    You didn't play towards your Wincon and lost. It makes perfect sense. The angle shooting cheating play style losing is also nice
    Was there anything involved in "not playing towards your wincon" besides claiming?
  9. Postgame#18325

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed Not quite also we would have disappeared

    Quote Originally Posted by katze (#18311)
    did the openclaiming 3ps win or lose thats all i care about
    Not quite
    also we would have disappeared
  10. Postgame#18314

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed yeah, but everyone else was confirmed town, and...

    Quote Originally Posted by Kane (#18303)
    Quote Originally Posted by SheepButBad (#18300)
    Quote Originally Posted by Kane (#18298)
    Quote Originally Posted by Fleur (#18297)
    Santy, we literally tried protecting you and Cider since you were the corrupted ones.
    ohh so I wasn't actually corrupted?
    yeah it was Cider, Santy, and Rhand
    That makes more sense, I think the biggest issue with those 3 is that they are before POE and are most likely going to have the chaos in the last 3.
    yeah, but everyone else was confirmed town, and could be peeked
    also it was Santy, then Cider, then Rhand (for immunity)
  11. Postgame#18300

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed yeah it was Cider, Santy, and Rhand

    Quote Originally Posted by Kane (#18298)
    Quote Originally Posted by Fleur (#18297)
    Santy, we literally tried protecting you and Cider since you were the corrupted ones.
    ohh so I wasn't actually corrupted?
    yeah it was Cider, Santy, and Rhand
  12. Postgame#18299

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed Santy was corrupted btw

    Quote Originally Posted by theknightsofneeee (#18287)
    Chaos mafia had a factional kill correct?

    What happened to the factional last night? I’m super curious
    Santy was corrupted btw
  13. Postgame#18282

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed Look at neighborhood chat it was the best

    Quote Originally Posted by Abraxas (#18281)
    outing the batman peek as red was the nail in our vampire coffin, i thought we agreed to team with him ?
    Look at neighborhood chat
    it was the best
  14. Postgame#18278

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed is there discord dvc?

    is there discord dvc?
  15. Postgame#18264

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed GG we almost got there also "You will leave...

    GG

    we almost got there
    also "You will leave the game upon winning"
  16. Day 6#18193

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed No Just me and Fleur are vampirires, as well as...

    Quote Originally Posted by Percy (#18188)
    Wasn’t Santy a Vamp?
    No
    Just me and Fleur are vampirires, as well as abraxas, who is dead.
  17. Day 6#18187

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed I hereby donate all of my RNG luck to Fleur

    I hereby donate all of my RNG luck to Fleur
  18. Day 6#18175

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed imagine if abraxas were still here also

    Quote Originally Posted by Ciderhead (#18172)
    I don't mean funny as in suspicious it just makes me laugh
    imagine if abraxas were still here also
  19. Day 6#18167

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed Santygrass

    ##Vote Santygrass
  20. Day 6#18162

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed I have pretty good RNG luck It'll balance out

    Quote Originally Posted by Fleur (#18160)
    Sheep doesn‘t know about my bad RNG luck.
    I have pretty good RNG luck
    It'll balance out
  21. Day 6#18155

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed probably the music I'm listening to

    Quote Originally Posted by Ciderhead (#18152)
    The contrast between Fleur's and Sheep's posting is so funny
    probably the music I'm listening to
  22. Day 6#18150

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed I'm down with that

    Quote Originally Posted by moth (#18145)
    put santy at three let it rand
    I'm down with that
  23. Day 6#18149

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed I just don't think I could convincingly push a...

    Quote Originally Posted by Grant (#18141)
    Quote Originally Posted by Grant (#18135)
    Quote Originally Posted by SheepButBad (#18121)
    faking redpeeks is hard though
    Or maybe you really did submit a peek, binked the chaos, and you're refusing to tell us who it is because defeating chaos apparently causes you to lose also.
    My point was: a fake redpeek is only a problem if you think you need to survive past today.
    I just don't think I could convincingly push a fake redpeek

    I had enough trouble with BATMAN, who was scum
  24. Day 6#18144

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed no fleur corrupted so they couldn't use the...

    Quote Originally Posted by Grant (#18135)
    Quote Originally Posted by SheepButBad (#18121)
    faking redpeeks is hard though
    Or maybe you really did submit a peek, binked the chaos, and you're refusing to tell us who it is because defeating chaos apparently causes you to lose also.
    no
    fleur corrupted so they couldn't use the check
    as to why we didn't neighborize idk
  25. Day 6#18139

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed uhhhh I mean I have slight paranoia on Grant...

    Quote Originally Posted by Ciderhead (#18131)
    Sheep honest to god outside of your wincon and all that who do you think is the most likely chaos here
    uhhhh
    I mean
    I have slight paranoia on Grant
    Percy is doing the things you guys accused tsp for
    Santy's probably scum if i'm being honest just because my reason for townreading them is kind of bad. Their treatment of vampires is interesting though.
    Idrk about knights
    If you were scum, you're either like a goon or godfather with a bpv or smth but I don't think you are scum.
  26. Day 6#18129

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed that's fair I don't think humans were designed...

    Quote Originally Posted by Ciderhead (#18125)
    My brain's mush at the moment I'm just clicking buttons I have no idea what I'm doing
    that's fair
    I don't think humans were designed to play in a mash for more than 5 days
  27. Day 6#18121

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed faking redpeeks is hard though

    Quote Originally Posted by Grant (#18118)
    Quote Originally Posted by Grant (#18114)
    ya this seems like a game-deciding vote for vamps.
    It's interesting though they didn't think this through and fake a redpeek to guaranteed the vote they wanted.
    faking redpeeks is hard though
  28. Day 6#18113

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed ah that's fair

    Quote Originally Posted by theknightsofneeee (#18111)
    Quote Originally Posted by SheepButBad (#18105)
    Quote Originally Posted by theknightsofneeee (#18104)
    We also shot both camps last night with kp, and neither died, amplifying the concern towards them
    is the concern just "they don't want to die"?
    It’s concerning cause if we mislynch we can’t just shoot you to potentially not lose

    Lol
    ah that's fair
  29. Day 6#18112

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed uh

    Quote Originally Posted by Percy (#18109)
    Quote Originally Posted by Fleur (#18100)
    Quote Originally Posted by Percy (#18094)
    Quote Originally Posted by Fleur (#18084)
    He‘s a potential Godfather and wants to vote Vamps instead of closing the PoE.
    Forgive me, my friend but if we’re going down that Godfather track, couldn’t the same be said of every other player in this game right now? Who of us can reliably NOT be considered to be a potential Godfather? What has Knights done that you believe makes him more likely to be a Godfather than any of the rest of the player population?

    I’m sorry too but I’m a bit behind (like about 30K posts) on the mechanics of this set up? What is wrong with voting ‘Vamps’ exactly? If we discount the ‘Vamps’ what PoE exactly does that leave us with?

    I sincerely appreciate your patience in working through all of this with me my friend.
    The PoE is anyone except Vamps, Xequalsy, Valentine, Moth and Grant rn because all of them are cleared more or less. Going after Vamps is ensuring that Town gets no info on anything and it wastes a day. I assume he‘s Godfather because he apparently scanned Town, but his behaviour matches a Chaos scum who is trying to buy time.
    OK, so am I to conclude from your post that, yourself, Xequalsy, Valentine, moth and Grant are all ‘Vamps’? And further, as you are all ‘Vamps’ there is some element of cross corroboration that supports those claims? You are also inferring through your post that ‘Vamps’ are to varying degrees PRs and that as a collective, you are willing to collaborate with us? That being the case, I can understand how voting to eliminate ‘Vamps’ might be seen as counterproductive but could that not also come from a mindset of a Townie simply not wanting to lose to the ‘Vamps’?
    uh
  30. Day 6#18105

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed is the concern just "they don't want to die"?

    Quote Originally Posted by theknightsofneeee (#18104)
    We also shot both camps last night with kp, and neither died, amplifying the concern towards them
    is the concern just "they don't want to die"?
  31. Day 6#18073

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed idts

    Quote Originally Posted by Fleur (#18072)
    Do people who don‘t min post just get modkilled?
    idts
  32. Day 6#18064

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed Be more ambitious, find scum!

    Quote Originally Posted by Ciderhead (#18062)
    I might vote Fleur and dip before they can shout at me
    Be more ambitious, find scum!
  33. Day 6#18061

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed Percy has the check I guess and the shot on tsp...

    Quote Originally Posted by Fleur (#18060)
    Percy has nothing clearing him, no. But he isn‘t even here rn.
    Percy has the check I guess
    and the shot on tsp ig?
  34. Day 6#18058

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed I don't think it's percy?

    Quote Originally Posted by Ciderhead (#18053)
    Or Percy?
    I don't think it's percy?
  35. Day 6#18055

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed uh it's not me, Fleur, Grant, Valentine, or...

    Quote Originally Posted by Ciderhead (#18054)
    Idk someone send help
    uh
    it's not me, Fleur, Grant, Valentine, or xequalsy
  36. Day 6#18048

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed They are diferent colors

    Quote Originally Posted by Mafia Host (#17221)
    Abraxas[/JUMP] Cubism
    They are diferent colors
  37. Day 6#18020

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed but when we leave, if it ends in more scum then...

    Quote Originally Posted by Fleur (#18019)
    This isn‘t lylo because we aren‘t game ending. We just leave the game.
    but when we leave, if it ends in more scum then town
    then they lose
  38. Day 6#18015

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed well if you insist theknightsofneeee

    Quote Originally Posted by theknightsofneeee (#18009)
    Keep in mind I’m at 4 votes in actuality because sheep isn’t voting
    well
    if you insist

    ##Vote theknightsofneeee
  39. Day 6#17928

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed rb works on anyone tbh

    Quote Originally Posted by theknightsofneeee (#17923)
    Quote Originally Posted by Grant (#17919)
    Let's say we leave Cider alive, cider's Mafia, and the vampires are pissed off so they somehow RB Valentine.

    Cider gets his kill off, we think he's clear, and then we're stuck wasting days killing villagers and/or headscratching suspicion that the Valentine RB didn't work.

    In this case I agree it's too easy for things to go wrong by announcing a plan to use RB as an investigation tool.
    fair enough

    but afaik their rb only works on people who they have corrupted

    which is pretty much exactly xequalsy/rhand because they didn't die to their kp last night

    and if we end up flipping the vamps and a rb flips we can reevaluate cider then?

    but i also didn't consider if there is a second chaos who could rb as well so yeah it is risky'ish
    rb works on anyone tbh
  40. Day 6#17910

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed I assume nk means no kill

    Quote Originally Posted by theknightsofneeee (#17907)
    Quote Originally Posted by Valentine (#17904)
    what stops chaos from nk and framing cider lol
    if there is a night kill we know it isn't cider lol
    I assume nk means no kill
  41. Day 6#17902

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed :thonk: this is very easily manipulatable

    Quote Originally Posted by theknightsofneeee (#17897)
    i know this is going to surprise everyone when i say this

    but we could always just lynch a vampire and just rb cider again

    and if no kp shows in the night again tomorrow we just kill cider
    :thonk:
    this is very easily manipulatable
  42. Day 6#17684

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed wheeeeeeeeeee

    wheeeeeeeeeee
  43. Day 6#17678

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed a vagabond?

    Quote Originally Posted by theknightsofneeee (#17669)
    i'm a v_________
    a vagabond?
  44. Day 6#17653

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed That's fair I mean not everything that I've...

    Quote Originally Posted by theknightsofneeee (#17651)
    if you're a villager you should just ignore anything the vamps are saying today because they're trying to hit their wincon and we need to solve the game

    everything they've said today feels SUPER agenda'y
    That's fair
    I mean
    not everything that I've said
    I'd love to see that argument
  45. Day 6#17652

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed I mean just kill Cider first?

    Quote Originally Posted by Fleur (#17646)
    Gonna repeat that the Knights green check comes from Cider who is in the PoE rn, so it's not exactly reliable.
    I mean
    just kill Cider first?
  46. Day 6#17650

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed If the number of corrupts + the number of...

    Quote Originally Posted by Kane (#17645)
    Which I'd love for more clarification on how they can win with town. Please restate this for me @SheepButBad since you seem to be the level headed one.
    If the number of corrupts + the number of vampires >= everyone else, we win and leave the game, and disappear back into our coffins or smth
  47. Day 6#17642

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed theknightsofneeee ok sir

    ##Unvote theknightsofneeee

    ok sir
  48. Day 6#17640

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed maybe there is arsonist or smth?

    maybe there is arsonist or smth?
  49. Day 6#17630

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed theknightsofneeee

    ##Vote theknightsofneeee
  50. Day 6#17629

    Thread: Warhammer Mash

    by SheepButBad
    Replies
    18,418
    Views
    127,125

    Completed ok

    Quote Originally Posted by Valentine (#17364)
    i rbed cider
    ok
Results 1 to 50 of 3000
Page 1 of 60 1 2 3 4
about us
Mafia Universe is a community hub for people who enjoy playing the forum variant of Mafia (also known as Werewolf). We offer fully automated Mafia games and a wide variety of customized features crafted to optimize your game experience. We also proudly host the Internet's only database of Mafia/Werewolf communities.

We hope you stick around!
Role of the Day
Steadfast Townie

The Steadfast Townie will kill anyone attempting to convert them at night. The Steadfast Townie can maximum kill 2 people with their ability, after which they will lose it.