Type: Posts; User: Hermione Granger
you can't do that on any night phase post night 1 though
It can be a only at start of night 1 thing and a public mechanic.
we also didn't modblock lurkers in anni for some reason that it was not discussed with me. I found it pretty lame myself
there was no player for a not modblocked town to use it unless if someone was replacing in
in case there was a replacement they didn't know anything about the game when those 30 players who could use the wolf action were already playing the game and were informed about the game state
so yeah no modblocking is pretty wolf sided in general - not saying in turned out to be in this game - because wolf team were pretty much active anyway.
What if we have a some sort of game mechanic that transfers the power roles from 0 posters to vts and don't modblock the slankers?
Like as a game mechanic. There are issues with this but I think something like this should solve the power removal from games
how does that change anything about how overpowered the role is?
When will you change your avatar
stop tilting me.
Like give me a break.
I called out more than 10 scums and pushed them all with my limited time.
I was not even remembering prince is alive with such role till last day which I was alive in and he contacted me with a claim list that was coordinated by mill crab. I read like less than 5% of thread overall and I was a vt.
I litteraly was pushing more than half of the flipped wolves and some of the unflipped ones and I read less than 5% of the game because of real life.
I don't know what are you trying to imply here? Why didn't YOU kill prince taldram? There are 132 slots in this game not just me.
great game smart bomb
you play spectacular with neighborhoods. I don't know why people keep trusting you when they are repeatedly proven that you're great in neighborhoods as scum and in pocketing people XD
Regardless, the role that can unlimitedly talk with everyone is a mass neighborizer. I don't udnerstand what do you mean when you say it's not.
And yes before you say anything else I said this more than enough that I agree that town played horrible in regards of that role and sb played it great. that's not the point I was trying to make so maybe read my post first and then decide to mock me for something that was not my responsibility or my mistake.
The role had a huge variance in its effect. It could be a disaster for scums or to give them what it did in this game. Both sides are wrong. a role with this huge variance that can nuke the game flow should not be in setups in first place or need huge restrictions/ways to escape.
I also understand the fun of that role and how much it's skill based. Neighbroizer is the most brilliant mafia role of all time. It's extremely dynamic, powerful and fun cause it's skill based.
I don't remember not putting a neighborizer in any large game I designed. I love it XD
I think SB role was extremely overdoing it and that you're underestimating how powerful the role and its impact is.
It's hard to see how it broke the game cause it didn't break it mechanically. If you don't like the word breaking, use the world too OP. I still stand by the word breaking based on following definition of game breaking mechanics from my article on good game designs:
The role is probably in top three of most powerful roles I ever encountered and first in that list is a role that could order the game host to modkill all slots XD
A mass neighbroizer is very different from a 1 person or 2 person per day neighborize. It's more powerful when it's 1v1 chats. And yeah its a double edge sword and if its played bad it's a death sentence. non of these means it didn't have so much utility or justifies it's ability to nuke the game flow.
yeah all three sentences are true:
Sb played it really well
Town played it really bad
The role nuked this game and broke it by getting so many claims/pocketing so many people
You must always consider the worst case scanrio with roles when balancing them. The role had "so much utility" that could nuke the game if played well/if people in opposite were playing bad. mass neighborizer was not a good role to be added to game because it gave the potential for nuking the game to sb and he used it.
neighbroizer is a double edge blade role
the role provides high utility for manipulation
and is perfect for other people so they can read u better
a mass neighborizer means the role is 1000 time more extreme in both cases
there were 2 billion ways to catch sb this game
and he had the utility to pocket everyone, get their claims and manage the game however he wanted
as both are possible > the role is providing too much utility - it is based on skill but still it's too much utility > the role is broken
the utility is that it can hunt So many claims
and to manage a lynch/ita shots
and effect everything indirectly
No one denies sb played a great game here
such role should not exist
Thanks for the game! It was really fun and I was really missing the action!
You should have listened to my Marko read
and I should have had a little time to show you scum in WG and wolfy as I was seeing them when I was alive.
This was one of those game were from my 20 reads, 19 were correct and accurate, and there was my roundabout read.
Though I tried to hint it was weaker than I was thinking in my last post.
I'm too tired to recheck based on what posts I started tring math. will do so tomorrow if I was alive
reduce the 95% to 90%
Roundabout made a derp way earlier that his town would know. he was playing to his town meta fully.
I think roundabout is town with a 95% certainty.
I have to stop and go to sleep before my body turns to ashes tbh.
why is grant town
and no I don't wish death in mafia games. I got 4 scum in this game with my limited time and effort and that was hard. It would be a great out if I would ie to that reflection from my last scum read instead of being in thread mostly useless and paranoid with red eyes and when all parts of my body hurts.
I would be happier if I was dieing by that mooni reflection yesterday instead of shad.
where were you all before me expressing my paranoia?
This is fishy af
I feel like most of the people in thread are wolves rn
I'm so tired to be of any use. this game is just in the worst period for me and I've been really busy with other things. yet I got the half of the flipped scums in this.
I'm going to bed before i die.
I think marko is scum. he doesn't have the spark of solving, he is not leading anything like he does when he is town. he is just in sideline telling his reads and those enever ended in a scum death.
am I wrong?
yeah thats what you get for putting a person who claims that in shot list
I hope they didn't have a confirmable role like they claimed whe I was reading their iso