Search:

Type: Posts; User: Frog

Page 1 of 60 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.15 seconds.

  1. Replies
    25
    Views
    465

    Walrus I'll ask friends family to help me out since I...

    I'll ask friends family to help me out since I seem to be on a nodium trend lately, but I'm 100% going to send you... stuff
  2. Day 1#773

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread DkKoba WerewolfHunter Sorry I have...

    @DkKoba
    @WerewolfHunter

    Sorry

    I have offended you both, and frankly I could have gone about making my points in a better way that wouldn't have you both mad at me.

    Again, I'm sorry.

    Literally yesterday I started taking something for my training that probably contributed to my demeanor, I'm going to take a light break from the game to get used to the side effects

    cheers bros and brodettes
  3. Day 1#772

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread Skimmed and not reading or responding to this...

    Quote Originally Posted by DkKoba (#770)
    Quote Originally Posted by DkKoba (#762)
    You are intentionally misrepresenting me and not even bothering to engage my thoughts in good faith.
    Why do you think that what i said couldn't have come from town?
    Because that is genuinely how i read and am updating my reads as new evidence presents itself.
    Now - saying I'm giving a pass to inactives, while i am voting an inactive - and while I am the top poster *by far* here - is extremely hypocritical of you.
    You skipped trying to convince me of your pov and into scumreading me - an unnatural progression.
    What's your read on TL and why?
    to add onto this:
    my only hesitance in full on burying you is that it is an extremely stupid move to openwolf against the 1 person who would have defended you to death. although at this point I think that if TL were to flip scum at any point, then you should be looked at in much higher scrutiny due to the weird interactions you have had here with that slot.

    Like deadass if you kept playing the way you were before this TL interaction(and even afterwards, if you didn't just straight try to fabricate a reason to vote me that's contradictory to reality), I would have probably actually *defended* you - if you're scum, realize this was a $%#! play from you and you should learn from this because i would hate to roll scum with you if this is the type of decisions you make, because from this point forward you've drawn full scrutiny from the only person proclaiming you were confidently town.
    Skimmed and not reading or responding to this dumpster fire

    Rather piss on it and put it out and move on

    I want more activity

    Your actions were contrary to my objectives

    I was shocked

    You git mad at Mt shock

    I explained my shock

    TL got mad at my shock

    I explained my shock

    Now I'm just mad that you're mad that I was shocked at your terrible move

    Move on

    It's a lot of nothing

    Don't give passes
  4. Day 1#771

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread Yes, and you too tbh Just got pissy

    Quote Originally Posted by DkKoba (#764)
    @Frog - do you townread WerewolfHunter?
    Yes, and you too tbh

    Just got pissy
  5. Day 1#761

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread I still have no idea what the heck DkKoba is...

    I still have no idea what the heck DkKoba is doing giving inactive players passes

    It is a MAJOR misplaced, or OVERTLY scummy

    I think both dkkoba and TL leaning into emotional $%#! and boxing me in with:

    'You mad bro?' Enough times is overtly scummy as people

    ##Vote dkkoba
  6. Day 1#760

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread No, I have a pass remember? Oh so dies...

    Quote Originally Posted by DkKoba (#759)
    i retract my locktown read on frog, this latest string of posts makes my heart feel *angery*.
    No, I have a pass remember?

    Oh so dies everyone

    Why bother to try

    ##Vote sleep

    Genius
  7. Day 1#758

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread Meh, I'm done caring about that dumb stuff ...

    Meh, I'm done caring about that dumb stuff

    @Trustworthy Liberal

    If you have taken offense, please know that it was never given

    However, know that you have personally offended me with your insinuations and I don't find that type of behavior acceptable

    I expect, based on your posting, that miscommunication is likely

    I encourage you to re-read my posts in their entirety

    I have taken time to respond to your posts thoroughly, and I expect you to do the same

    What you have replied with is insulting

    gl gl
  8. Day 1#757

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread I agree At this point I take personal offense...

    Quote Originally Posted by DkKoba (#755)
    something abt the frog/TL interactions doesn't feel right :/
    I agree

    At this point I take personal offense to this accusation.

    Insinuating that I have crossed a line... crosses a line for me.

    This is personal tbh
  9. Day 1#756

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread Once again 1. Read post 734 all the way to the...

    Quote Originally Posted by Trustworthy Liberal (#754)
    Quote Originally Posted by Frog (#752)
    @Trustworthy Liberal

    read post 734, all the way to the end

    I am being extremely patient with you right now, and I am close to voting you all game, all day, every day, on the policy that you aren't actually reading replies.
    It's not an answer you legit said pass to reading or responding so I hold what I say and this response is just saying no one should play cause me coming in trying to be nice has been shown only harss words so as I said above this is my last response to you here now.

    As if you look at every post you have pointed towards me has been extremely harshly worded.

    Good night 💤

    Nya~
    Once again

    1. Read post 734 all the way to the bottom

    2. Point out exactly where you think I crossed a line in the way I'm talking to you

    Until then I will keep my vote on you for the duration of the game with no further content
  10. Day 1#753

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread You know what Trustworthy Liberal Policy...

    You know what

    ##Vote Trustworthy Liberal

    Policy time

    Point out exactly where you think I crossed a line in the way I'm talking to you
  11. Day 1#752

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread Trustworthy Liberal read post 734, all the way...

    @Trustworthy Liberal

    read post 734, all the way to the end

    I am being extremely patient with you right now, and I am close to voting you all game, all day, every day, on the policy that you aren't actually reading replies.
  12. Day 1#751

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread What are you even talking about? I answered you

    Quote Originally Posted by Trustworthy Liberal (#750)
    Quote Originally Posted by Trustworthy Liberal (#731)
    Quote Originally Posted by Frog (#730)
    Quote Originally Posted by DkKoba (#729)
    the pass is strictly for d1 why are you upset at that?
    I am unhappy, disappointed, and worried at your decision to give them a 'pass' for today.

    It is as nonsensical as the literally made up reads list they posted earlier this month.

    I am unhappy because my objective is to get the players who haven't been playing to play MORE. Why? So I can actually get better engagement and reads with them. The state of the game is currently not conducive to getting those results, until I expressed my disatisfaction. Then we have some of the UTR players popping out the woodowrks, and you're like, 'it's ok, no need to contribute anymore, you get a pass today'. Seriously, what are you doing?

    I am disappointed because it felt like your aim was also to increase activity, but your decision to grant a d1 pass off of nothing for a non-playing player goes against that.

    I am worried because the nonsensical decision to give a day 1 pass doesn't make sense given TL's content this game. It makes me doubt you again.

    The definition of upset.
    It's simply DkKoba trying to pocket me
    better question since i just double checked.

    If you disagree with them giving any credit for that post whats your thoughts as you seem to be extremly agavated at that single post hum????
    @Frog

    Right here.

    And if that's how you want to talk to be bye I'll come back when someone else is willing to talk to me as a person.
    What are you even talking about?

    I answered you
  13. Day 1#749

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread honestly, I think TL is probably Town lmfao ...

    honestly, I think TL is probably Town lmfao

    probably refine my search in here:
    ##Vote Sheepsaysmeep
    lendunistus
    Michelle
    Cuthalion
  14. Day 1#748

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread Trustworthy Liberal what is the question that...

    Quote Originally Posted by Trustworthy Liberal (#743)
    You still didn't anwser the question of thoughts in that post.
    @Trustworthy Liberal

    what is the question that I didn't answer, because I'm positive I addressed your post thoroughly, and you still walked away with an incorrect conclusion on my demeanour

    Instead you respond with

    'You mad bro?'

    'You mad bro?'

    'You mad bro?'

    I'm assuming there is some miscommunication
  15. Day 1#746

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread I understand the situation. dkKoba says I'm...

    Quote Originally Posted by Trustworthy Liberal (#743)
    Cool am in the hole you imagine me in I saw this as a low engagement game when I felt like it.

    You still didn't anwser the question of thoughts in that post.

    Now please stop taking your frustration on this game on soly me and that's not fair in the slightest if you want to kill me cause the game across the board has not been very ingagy what ever I guess?

    But your bleed anger across most likely more then just here well here I suggest taking a chill pill.

    I understand this sounds harsher then I wished but really I enjoy playing with you normally dude take care of yourself.
    I understand the situation.

    dkKoba says I'm upset.

    You say I'm extremely aggravated.

    You say I'm frustrated.

    You say I bleed anger.

    The truth is I'm not really any of these things. I'm addressing how I could fit into those categories to appease you two, and in doing so I'm focusing on the box that you want to put me in. You're still focusing on the box instead of realizing... maybe I exist outside that box

    This all stemmed from inacitivty, which after I addressed the inactivity, the inactive players began playing.

    Then dkKoba incentivized you, the inactive player, to stop playing. Which is when I, understandably, wanted to understand what the heck dkKoba was doing making such a massive misplay. Calling out suboptimal plays is not the same as being angry, frustrated, extrmeely agitated, etc.

    There is nothing really emotional attached to it other than shock and surprise.

    Anger would be like hostility, and to be frank, I'm addressing your posts with great detail and if you reread them as though I'm speaking in a calm voice, maybe you'll realize I'm approaching this rather objectively.

    Bottom line, play the game bro or get yeeted

    ##Vote Trustworthy Liberal
  16. Day 1#744

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread lendunistus lendunistus let's go bro

    ##Vote lendunistus

    @lendunistus

    let's go bro
  17. Day 1#742

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread just went through gnomes ISO if you want to...

    just went through gnomes ISO

    if you want to know someone who gets a pass day 1, it's gnome

    really good stuff there
  18. Day 1#741

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread there aren't this many wolves

    there aren't this many wolves
  19. Day 1#740

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread sheepsaysmeep has only missed two months,...

    ##Vote sheepsaysmeep

    has only missed two months, actually regularly checks in to the game and has provided next to nothing

    semi-active wolf chat keeps them coming back to post more regularly but not actually do anything?
  20. Day 1#739

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread I realize I'm treating Ara and Ampharos...

    I realize I'm treating Ara and Ampharos differently in my head.

    Right now I was ready to say:

    Amy is just Mafia who did enough to coast, and just put the game on the back burner and went away on vacation to tahiti drinking fancy fruit juices etc.

    whereas Ara, who did the exact same thing, I was ready to flip my read and just say, eh they're town, they showed leadership to actually organize town at some point this game which counts for something I guess, especially seeing Ara as a warmarshal type town player

    But essentially they both have very similar patterns? Is it unfair to conclude that I Town read Ara, but I suspect Amy?
  21. Day 1#738

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread Marshal What happened to reading michelle ...

    Quote Originally Posted by Marshal (#725)
    this exists

    shame im not gonna do anything about it
    @Marshal

    What happened to reading michelle

    Also, I think Michelle asked you questions
  22. Day 1#737

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread Also Ignoramus

    Also
    ##Vote Ignoramus
  23. Day 1#736

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread Also Ampharos

    Also

    ##Vote Ampharos
  24. Day 1#735

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread imagine the bar is so low that attempting to play...

    Quote Originally Posted by DkKoba (#733)
    Quote Originally Posted by Frog (#730)
    Quote Originally Posted by DkKoba (#729)
    the pass is strictly for d1 why are you upset at that?
    I am unhappy, disappointed, and worried at your decision to give them a 'pass' for today.

    It is as nonsensical as the literally made up reads list they posted earlier this month.

    I am unhappy because my objective is to get the players who haven't been playing to play MORE. Why? So I can actually get better engagement and reads with them. The state of the game is currently not conducive to getting those results, until I expressed my disatisfaction. Then we have some of the UTR players popping out the woodowrks, and you're like, 'it's ok, no need to contribute anymore, you get a pass today'. Seriously, what are you doing?

    I am disappointed because it felt like your aim was also to increase activity, but your decision to grant a d1 pass off of nothing for a non-playing player goes against that.

    I am worried because the nonsensical decision to give a day 1 pass doesn't make sense given TL's content this game. It makes me doubt you again.

    The definition of upset.
    i think its enough to give them a pass over the other people I think deserve a lim today.

    I'm trying to slowly raise the bar, come and help!
    imagine the bar is so low that attempting to play the game means you don't get yeeted :-P

    I'm working on something for this game actually, about halfway done and then I'll have a better idea of where I think we should go next

    Relevant to what I'm working on:

    Do you think Mafia are more likely to check in regularly, even if minimal?
    Or do you think they'd check in sparsely, doing just enough to coast, and then ghost?
    Or both?
    Or Neither?
  25. Day 1#734

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread annoyed, exasperated, especially persistently, to...

    Quote Originally Posted by Trustworthy Liberal (#731)
    Quote Originally Posted by Frog (#730)
    Quote Originally Posted by DkKoba (#729)
    the pass is strictly for d1 why are you upset at that?
    I am unhappy, disappointed, and worried at your decision to give them a 'pass' for today.

    It is as nonsensical as the literally made up reads list they posted earlier this month.

    I am unhappy because my objective is to get the players who haven't been playing to play MORE. Why? So I can actually get better engagement and reads with them. The state of the game is currently not conducive to getting those results, until I expressed my disatisfaction. Then we have some of the UTR players popping out the woodowrks, and you're like, 'it's ok, no need to contribute anymore, you get a pass today'. Seriously, what are you doing?

    I am disappointed because it felt like your aim was also to increase activity, but your decision to grant a d1 pass off of nothing for a non-playing player goes against that.

    I am worried because the nonsensical decision to give a day 1 pass doesn't make sense given TL's content this game. It makes me doubt you again.

    The definition of upset.
    It's simply DkKoba trying to pocket me
    better question since i just double checked.

    If you disagree with them giving any credit for that post whats your thoughts as you seem to be extremly agavated at that single post hum????
    annoyed, exasperated, especially persistently, to a very great degree

    I'm annoyed because after I made a couple of posts calling out the nonposters 710711, and non players actually seemed to respond and start playing 714717, dkkoba is seemingly attempting to play the positive response down.

    I'm not exasperated, it may only seem as such because of the specific question asked by dkKoba, 'why are you upset', to which I'm addressing the definition of upset and how my mindset might fit into that definition. Similarly, I am replying to your content which is about 'extremely agavated', and I'm doing the same thing. If you were to ask me about happiness and jotfulness, I think you'd find my content relevant to the subject matter.

    I'm somewhat persistent, in that I'm following up, but I'm not going above and beyond.

    And I would have to characterize to a very great degree as being inaccurate, but you do you.

    As for my thoughts on your one post? Pass. Let's talk about your overall content.

    You posted 3 times in january using a gimmick, which, kind of feels like scummy, like mafia trying to make the game funny, but the joke is only funny to you?

    Then you abandon the game for February, March, April.

    You post once in May, dropping the gimmick but adding nothing.

    Only to disappear for two more months in June and July.

    Then reappear in August promising to play, but you don't in your two posts there.

    And finally, FINALLY, we're in September, and you are now in double digit posts because the spotlight is growing around you.

    Bro, no. I'm not giving you a pass off of one post. You're interacting with another non-player asking questions to which you, yourself, seem to lack answers.

    I commend the attitude that you're taking to actually play the game, but you're no where out of the hole you dug yourself into.
  26. Day 1#730

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread I am unhappy, disappointed, and worried at your...

    Quote Originally Posted by DkKoba (#729)
    the pass is strictly for d1 why are you upset at that?
    I am unhappy, disappointed, and worried at your decision to give them a 'pass' for today.

    It is as nonsensical as the literally made up reads list they posted earlier this month.

    I am unhappy because my objective is to get the players who haven't been playing to play MORE. Why? So I can actually get better engagement and reads with them. The state of the game is currently not conducive to getting those results, until I expressed my disatisfaction. Then we have some of the UTR players popping out the woodowrks, and you're like, 'it's ok, no need to contribute anymore, you get a pass today'. Seriously, what are you doing?

    I am disappointed because it felt like your aim was also to increase activity, but your decision to grant a d1 pass off of nothing for a non-playing player goes against that.

    I am worried because the nonsensical decision to give a day 1 pass doesn't make sense given TL's content this game. It makes me doubt you again.

    The definition of upset.
  27. Day 1#728

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread You think this one post is enough to take them...

    Quote Originally Posted by DkKoba (#724)
    Quote Originally Posted by Trustworthy Liberal (#723)
    Quote Originally Posted by WerewolfHunter (#718)
    Quote Originally Posted by Wesmaster160 (#712)
    I want to weigh in on this. Yes, I haven't checked in too often but that's how I like to do these long games. I'm also back in college in person so I have less time. I feel like not being on as much as everyone else, doesn't mean that I'm not playing.
    Gonna reword and form the question that I expected the others to ask.

    Understand you have less time BUT this should take but an hour of time divide that over a week or so if you want well wait... Or atleast I will.

    1: what's your thoughts on what you previously read? Unsure if you keep notes more what this is for.

    2: looking back over thread 15 pages 700ish pages even reading just a majority of need by what are thoughts on some players?

    3: gth you have to make a top three town and bottom three wolfs who is it and why. Which of those wolfs would you be most included to vote today?
    ok this post is towny

    or at least it appears towny


    regardless TL gets to be locktabled for d1.
    You think this one post is enough to take them out of discussion entirely for today?

    Dude, what are you even doing?

    You can still be town but you're getting exiled to the outskirts of the town

    Not giving UTR players passes for literally one day of posting after not playing all game

    SRS

    no
  28. Postgame#1232

    Thread: The Memes Game (MAFIA WINS)

    by Frog
    Replies
    1,231
    Views
    8,212

    Completed Weapons-grade memes enriched with uranium ...

    Quote Originally Posted by King Bowser (#687)
    Weapons-grade memes enriched with uranium

    Amazing bro
  29. Replies
    112
    Views
    2,979

    Manual Definitely can't play but looks hype!!!! ...

    Definitely can't play but looks hype!!!!

    /unspoiled spec ?
  30. #61

    Thread: SPF Walrus

    by Frog
    Replies
    70
    Views
    2,102

    Kane BlueKang Moose So we meet again! ...

    @Kane
    @BlueKang
    @Moose

    So we meet again!

    We shall see who triumphs in this race to the bottom
  31. Replies
    22
    Views
    422

    Walrus For this brief moment I am in first place

    For this brief moment I am in first place
  32. Day 1#711

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread I'm nearing the point where I'm going to policy...

    I'm nearing the point where I'm going to policy eliminate all of these slots, and I don't care if they get replaced or mod peeked town or whatever. I'm just not happy with the level of play. Not playing isn't a strategy. It's not playing.
  33. Day 1#710

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread I assumed long phases meant there was a lot of...

    I assumed long phases meant there was a lot of time to rest between playing, but there's a solid fourth of the game not playing.
  34. Day 1#708

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread I think that's a towny mindset coming from you,...

    Quote Originally Posted by DkKoba (#707)
    Quote Originally Posted by Frog (#701)
    Quote Originally Posted by DkKoba (#700)
    me: scumreads 3 people confidently

    you: outs a list of 5 people that dont include any of the 3 people i mainly scumread

    one of my scumreads: says your readslist is good

    me: concludes there is a lot of town in that list assuming that the scumread is correct

    you: OmG iS ThAt A slIP


    2nd time this game you tried to pretend like i slipped

    maybe stop assuming everyone has english as their first language
    Chill broseidon, I wanted to understand your perspective. I'm not resigned to read you a certain way, but if something gives me pause I'll let you know and give you the opportunity to address it. I'm traveling at the moment but on skim read I think that makes sense from your POV. So You're just saying you disagree with my heart list of 5 players, okay, no big deal.
    it also stood out to me bc wes at the time was not voting any of those people
    I think that's a towny mindset coming from you, even if Wes is Town, just being vigilant about other players point of views. Ok that makes sense, cheers!
  35. Day 1#704

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread *fakey dakey

    *fakey dakey
  36. Day 1#703

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread Not just random, garbage tier random that it...

    Quote Originally Posted by Trustworthy Liberal (#696)
    Quote Originally Posted by Frog (#694)
    Quote Originally Posted by Trustworthy Liberal (#691)
    Skimmed thread and eh only a few thoughts maybe cause i skimm weekly but run out of time heres current thoughts if i was to tier everyone no special colors cause phone

    Confident Town
    Visorslash
    Cuthalion
    Werewolf Hunter

    Town
    Ampharos
    Shad
    Wesmaster
    sheepsaysmeep

    Town Lean
    Frog
    Marshal
    Garden Gnome

    Null
    lenden
    General
    Ignoramus

    Scum Lean
    Ara
    Michelle
    DKkoba
    Why would you post a fake readlist? smh @Trustworthy Liberal
    You think it's random?

    Well parts of it arnt but I don't overly hate the list looking at it honestly so keeping it skimmed fast but okay with this roughly for now.

    Nya~
    Not just random, garbage tier random that it feels super fake dakey
  37. Day 1#701

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread Chill broseidon, I wanted to understand your...

    Quote Originally Posted by DkKoba (#700)
    me: scumreads 3 people confidently

    you: outs a list of 5 people that dont include any of the 3 people i mainly scumread

    one of my scumreads: says your readslist is good

    me: concludes there is a lot of town in that list assuming that the scumread is correct

    you: OmG iS ThAt A slIP


    2nd time this game you tried to pretend like i slipped

    maybe stop assuming everyone has english as their first language
    Chill broseidon, I wanted to understand your perspective. I'm not resigned to read you a certain way, but if something gives me pause I'll let you know and give you the opportunity to address it. I'm traveling at the moment but on skim read I think that makes sense from your POV. So You're just saying you disagree with my heart list of 5 players, okay, no big deal.
  38. Day 1#694

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread Why would you post a fake readlist? smh...

    Quote Originally Posted by Trustworthy Liberal (#691)
    Skimmed thread and eh only a few thoughts maybe cause i skimm weekly but run out of time heres current thoughts if i was to tier everyone no special colors cause phone

    Confident Town
    Visorslash
    Cuthalion
    Werewolf Hunter

    Town
    Ampharos
    Shad
    Wesmaster
    sheepsaysmeep

    Town Lean
    Frog
    Marshal
    Garden Gnome

    Null
    lenden
    General
    Ignoramus

    Scum Lean
    Ara
    Michelle
    DKkoba
    Why would you post a fake readlist? smh @Trustworthy Liberal
  39. Day 1#693

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread It's a real slip ~25% of the time, but if it is...

    Quote Originally Posted by Trustworthy Liberal (#689)
    Quote Originally Posted by Frog (#688)
    @DkKoba

    The longer you don't explain yourself, the more I'm inclined to believe you slipped up as Mafia.
    Wait theres a slip



    ##Vote DkKoba
    It's a real slip ~25% of the time, but if it is real, the spew is a group of 5 players, the majority of which are Town, assuming ~1 wolf in that group of 5 then.
  40. Day 1#688

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread DkKoba The longer you don't explain yourself,...

    @DkKoba

    The longer you don't explain yourself, the more I'm inclined to believe you slipped up as Mafia.
  41. Day 1#687

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread https://thumbs.gfycat.com/DishonestAdmiredDiplodoc...

  42. Day 1#686

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread https://youtu.be/cMVmw1_mN44?t=28

  43. Day 1#685

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread I fully understand you were talking to Wes, and I...

    Quote Originally Posted by DkKoba (#683)
    Quote Originally Posted by Frog (#681)
    Quote Originally Posted by DkKoba (#679)
    You're appealing to town to convince them to have a near full town scumread list lol
    Wait I just woke up
    wasn't @ you and was just my conclusion of what was going on there with a scum!wes
    I fully understand you were talking to Wes, and I can even imagine that you may have been speaking from Wes' point of view.

    What I don't understand is how you arrive to the conclusion, from Wes point of view, that Wes sees the majority of players of this group as Town:
    [GH
    Ara
    Ampharos
    Cuthalion
    Trustworthy Liberal]

    I am having trouble following your logic. Can you please, in excruciating detail, step by step, explain what you meant here?
  44. Day 1#684

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread I will preface this post by saying that my...

    Quote Originally Posted by DkKoba (#682)
    Quote Originally Posted by Frog (#680)
    Quote Originally Posted by DkKoba (#679)
    Wes, your vote is on michelle.but that list isnt that crazy?
    You're appealing to town to convince them to have a near full town scumread list lol

    @Frog why do you townread michelle and wes?
    I don't? They're not in my top town, nor in my top scum. They're in the ethereal 'idunno'


    how come for wes? they're one of the top posters so far, wondering what is preventing them from having a read -(something I think is scum indicative when I reach that analysis but I acknowledge that others' reading style is vastly different to mine)
    I will preface this post by saying that my responses here will not generate anything meaningful for you, for me, or for anyone really. So if you are reading this, feel free to skip this post.

    What are you hoping to gain from asking me these series of questions. Over the last week or so I don't think I've asked one question, I've just been reading along, answering questions and making stances. You and Wes have both been like, 'I'm going to ask a billion questions for reason X'. I just feel like nothing meaningful can actually be learned here and it's just clogging up the thread.

    Now to answer your questions... again.


    Quote Originally Posted by DkKoba (#682)
    how come for wes?
    I understand that you are leaning heavily into the 'English isn't my first language' (it isn't my first language either), but I found it interesting you used the phrase 'How come'. Just a random piece of interest.

    Quote Originally Posted by DkKoba (#682)
    how come for wes? they're one of the top posters so far, wondering what is preventing them from having a read -(something I think is scum indicative when I reach that analysis but I acknowledge that others' reading style is vastly different to mine)
    They post a lot. They put feeling into what they say. They make reads. They take stances. They're actually playing the game. Should Wes be a town? I'm just not seeing anything to feel confident about there.

    GH, Ara, and Ampharos are similar in that they played the game, they made reads, they took stances, but... I'm just not feeling it from them. Follow me here; I'm imagining that THEY (GH, Ara, Ampharos) believe that they have passed the posting threshold of play and interacting, and have therefore earned the right to just coast. That FEELS scummy to me.

    Whereas Wes hasn't taken a back seat, they've been more consistently present.

    So at minimum I don't have Wes in the scum pile, but I don't have them in town pile either. Maybe that helps explain my headspace, but like, I don't think it's actually useful to you or anyone else.
  45. Day 1#681

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread Wait I just woke up

    Quote Originally Posted by DkKoba (#679)
    You're appealing to town to convince them to have a near full town scumread list lol
    Wait I just woke up
  46. Day 1#680

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread I don't? They're not in my top town, nor in my...

    Quote Originally Posted by DkKoba (#679)
    Wes, your vote is on michelle.but that list isnt that crazy?
    You're appealing to town to convince them to have a near full town scumread list lol

    @Frog why do you townread michelle and wes?
    I don't? They're not in my top town, nor in my top scum. They're in the ethereal 'idunno'
  47. Day 1#676

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread You know what, I'm going to tell you what my...

    You know what, I'm going to tell you what my heart thinks about this game

    I think the wolf team is 4 in this 5:
    GeneralHankerchief
    Arapocalypse
    Ampharos
    Cuthalion
    Trustworthy Liberal

    And you know why? Because that's how I feel! Is it a misplay? Almost certainly! Chances are it's filled with Town that's going to have trust issues with me for the remainder of the game, but I gotta be real with myself.

    If you're on this list and want to talk to it out with me, please, talk it out with me!!! I'd rather if you're Town do what you can to help me clear my stomach butterflies when I think about your slots this game than just harbor this feeling until I have to make decisions and wing it
  48. Day 1#675

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread From my recollection everyone who has commented...

    Quote Originally Posted by Wesmaster160 (#674)
    Quote Originally Posted by Frog (#673)
    Quote Originally Posted by Wesmaster160 (#672)

    Quote Originally Posted by Frog (#670)
    Invoking the rule of 3 is interesting, i forgot about that being a thing. Im not sure if its applicable here? No one was asking Marshal for a list, or suspects, he just kind of dived into it unprompted, unsolicited.

    Just checked back and ut looks like Marshal led the charge making that 'list', so points for first?

    I dont really know what to think about wes / michelle. My ego wants the howdy thing to be real, and i want it to bevl that easy, but its probably not.

    Off the cuff, I think its probably more difficult like:
    (GH / Ampharos / Ara / Cuth / Sheep) <- those being better hits rather than
    (Michelle / WWH / Marshal / Lendunistus)
    I think the only hit in the non player pile is Trustworthy Liberal, and even that is like... a coin flip at best.


    Why Cuth in the better hit pile compared to Michelle and WWH?
    The main reason is intuition. I just think Cuth is wolfing this game.

    I think the widespread sus WWH received probably spews them Town. Michelle I have as null, was hoping Marshal would do something there
    Without going back and checking, the only questionable push onto WWH was Igno, and possibly Marshall, and even then you lean them town. Seemed like the rest came from towny people to my recollection. Don't remember if Ara mentioned them. Biggest names I am remembering in regards to it are GH/Shad and maybe Visor.
    From my recollection everyone who has commented on WWH has been like 'yeah I guess they wolf', I don't really know anyone who has been like, 'you know what, I think this dude might be town'. That's kind of my point with that slot. Everyone is just okay with putting them in the 'yeah could chop this' pile.

    Although, to be fair, I don't remember anything they've actually done, let alone anything towny. My read on them is playing around them rather than a direct read.

    You can say that 'towny people' sussed them, but like, with a game this inactive, how many people can you actually confidently say, 'these people are Town for sure'? And then go a step further and base reads banking on those people actually being Town? Like, that's too many steps of confidence ahead of my mindset on the game.

    I'm trying to think of how many players I can confidently say are Town. Like if suddenly we were in LYLO, who would I automatically assume is Town and ride with? Visor and DkKoba, and maybe Marshal? There are people I WANT to be Town, like Shad, but I don't think I can put them in that category. I don't really think anyone else comes close? Oh Gnome is pretty pure I guess, but I wouldn't be able to ride with them yet.

    Let's look at who you calling Towny. YEah I just don't see GH as Towny. Honestly, I think they're a wolf and I have no good way of explaining why I get that feeling, but I'll try. They comment, a lot, but nothing seems alignment indicative for them. The only takes they've made with actual stakes are on me, which I know is a wrong take, at this point it's a stale take, and it feels like an excuse for later on to explain away why they haven't been night killed. Like 'oh I guess my reads were bad'. The other part of me is like, GH should be mostly self-resolving so just ignore them and play on. But, I wouldn't be able to get to GH = Town and then base reads off of that personally.
  49. Day 1#673

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread The main reason is intuition. I just think Cuth...

    Quote Originally Posted by Wesmaster160 (#672)

    Quote Originally Posted by Frog (#670)
    Quote Originally Posted by DkKoba (#668)
    Quote Originally Posted by Frog (#666)
    I dont remember, but I rarely see mafia world build complete / close to complete mafia teams this early:


    DKkoba/wes/frog/+1 lock it in ez

    This alone woupd have had me town read them early, even if I hadnt mentioned it. Oh I did mention it in 384

    390 - i had something about theur back and forth with you, but now I dont think it means much of anything

    I think if Marshal is Town, they havent done much of anything and can / maybe will be easily pushed by Mafia, but I stand by my read that theyre probably 99% town for making a wolf team guess early
    i find the latter post to be a fancy version of a "rule of 3" where they put in 2 towns 1 maf in the list.

    Its not that I read marshal scum based on their own postings but moreso spewed off wes/michelle being scum
    Invoking the rule of 3 is interesting, i forgot about that being a thing. Im not sure if its applicable here? No one was asking Marshal for a list, or suspects, he just kind of dived into it unprompted, unsolicited.

    Just checked back and ut looks like Marshal led the charge making that 'list', so points for first?

    I dont really know what to think about wes / michelle. My ego wants the howdy thing to be real, and i want it to bevl that easy, but its probably not.

    Off the cuff, I think its probably more difficult like:
    (GH / Ampharos / Ara / Cuth / Sheep) <- those being better hits rather than
    (Michelle / WWH / Marshal / Lendunistus)
    I think the only hit in the non player pile is Trustworthy Liberal, and even that is like... a coin flip at best.


    Why Cuth in the better hit pile compared to Michelle and WWH?
    The main reason is intuition. I just think Cuth is wolfing this game.

    I think the widespread sus WWH received probably spews them Town. Michelle I have as null, was hoping Marshal would do something there
  50. Day 1#670

    Thread: The Longest Mafia Game Redux

    by Frog
    Replies
    784
    Views
    20,230

    Game Thread Invoking the rule of 3 is interesting, i forgot...

    Quote Originally Posted by DkKoba (#668)
    Quote Originally Posted by Frog (#666)
    Quote Originally Posted by DkKoba (#657)
    also great segway to ask you frog, if you could list why you townread marshall outside their tone/emotion?
    I dont remember, but I rarely see mafia world build complete / close to complete mafia teams this early:

    Quote Originally Posted by Marshal (#132)
    DKkoba/wes/frog/+1 lock it in ez
    This alone woupd have had me town read them early, even if I hadnt mentioned it. Oh I did mention it in 384

    390 - i had something about theur back and forth with you, but now I dont think it means much of anything

    I think if Marshal is Town, they havent done much of anything and can / maybe will be easily pushed by Mafia, but I stand by my read that theyre probably 99% town for making a wolf team guess early
    i find the latter post to be a fancy version of a "rule of 3" where they put in 2 towns 1 maf in the list.

    Its not that I read marshal scum based on their own postings but moreso spewed off wes/michelle being scum
    Invoking the rule of 3 is interesting, i forgot about that being a thing. Im not sure if its applicable here? No one was asking Marshal for a list, or suspects, he just kind of dived into it unprompted, unsolicited.

    Just checked back and ut looks like Marshal led the charge making that 'list', so points for first?

    I dont really know what to think about wes / michelle. My ego wants the howdy thing to be real, and i want it to bevl that easy, but its probably not.

    Off the cuff, I think its probably more difficult like:
    (GH / Ampharos / Ara / Cuth / Sheep) <- those being better hits rather than
    (Michelle / WWH / Marshal / Lendunistus)
    I think the only hit in the non player pile is Trustworthy Liberal, and even that is like... a coin flip at best.
Results 1 to 50 of 3000
Page 1 of 60 1 2 3 4
about us
Mafia Universe is a community hub for people who enjoy playing the forum variant of Mafia (also known as Werewolf). We offer fully automated Mafia games and a wide variety of customized features crafted to optimize your game experience. We also proudly host the Internet's only database of Mafia/Werewolf communities.

We hope you stick around!
Role of the Day
Vanillaizer

The Vanillaizer may each night target a player, stripping them of any abilities that they may or may not have, effectively turning them into a vanilla role beginning the following night.