I'm a slow reader
Type: Posts; User: Izzy
I'm a slow reader
Only just caught up... feel like I should have won.
Well you let your best player die...
Nutella is scum
Neither are scum
##Vote andracass
It's a shame you'd actually enjoy reading our games and how they play outI found that you play on a Facebook group. So I do not think there is anything I can read.
Well, at least claim your role before you disappear, because if you do not do anything better you are going to be shot
I come from a community of love...
I sound really bitter but if you ever compare me to that...
Fossil came out say he was sus of chimp...
Defended rp'ing... voted Ex for, ummm rp'ing (oh damn)
Comes in saying I look sus on page 28... we where on page 37/38.... helpful
Then says that he couldn't be bothered to catch up and throws up a vote..
LATP
Look At The Posts
Nice
Huh... so his reads are where??
LATP
Have I not contributed?
Or have I come up with piss poor reasons as to why I'm not involved?
Elaborate?
Why? Because bullshizz like this doesn't help town or scum... if you don't have the time to play or keep up get out
Him...
I really hope you get subbed
He was voting to move conversation, as he claims it worked with you. Can't fault it
Thank you... also check that gender mate
Offers no reads?? You clearly don't follow along...
Mate you've done nothing all game please come up with an original idea.You’re suspicious. All of your posts are without substance. It lacks interest, your reasons are pretty flimsy, and over all feels like you’re wanting to just watch the game go to $#@!.
Sure it’s not scum indicative, but it’s not very helpful to town either. Pretty much I have you as someone to ignore now. Your behavior is disruptive to town. If you want to start somewhere, give me a read list of town, null, and scum. List your reasons as to why, too. Flimsy reasons are fine for now as long as you have evidence to back it up.
I’m planning on doing the same when I get time.
You what mate?
What?It is, town should be actively solving the game and trying to get out of the Poe somewhat rather than just happily sitting in the null zone
You say it as if it was a bad thing
You are grasping at strawsIt was either that or 'hey guys great to be here, this is going to be so much fun' but I'd rather not lie(Duskfall is one of said europeans but he's a degenerate and probably still awake anyway)Hey where did everyone go
(oh right half of you are european gn)
@Duskfall @Enoch Kaine talk more about your suspicions of me pls so I can tell you why you are wrong
why is this your entranceYour scumsenses? need a tissue..It's a mix. Earlier his aggressiveness twords bissy triggered some of my scumsenses, but then most players seemingly cleared him for being genuine because of his "not giving a hoot" attitude, which imo is the easieast route for scum to take in any given mafia game.
The last three posts i quoted are just like a big wtf for me because as i already said it's not helping ua try and figure out the game if he is town.Izzy looking very very thin.
Comes across as disinterested (could be a good reason for it) but a weird self assurance...
##Vote Izzy
??
BothI don’t know if to either ironically clap or to cry when I read this post.
Mob baiting at it's finest
I thougtt there was 3 with a possible 4th.. didn't know there was 4 off the bat..
I haven't read you as scum... but definitely someone who would cry over the spilled milk and not the house being on fire... you know what I mean
This comes with experience, these aren't simply "bets" this comes from hours upon hours of practice until I'm able to do this with my eyes closed. I call shots not guesses..Look, I get it. I get the fun of calling out your "bets" or gut reads to see if you can name the scum early on and look cool later. I've done it. But you need to follow it up with some actual hunting.
I guess you can call what you did effort if this was your first game ever... But I'm going to take a swing and say it's not... So what you did was piss poor, yelp review 1-starAre you being serious right now? Tell me, what is effort Izzy?If that's effort then I'm completely stumped
Don't need to play baseball to call your shotsIf you were right you would have made a lucky guess. You're not right though.But when I'm right did I not then solve the game??You seem extremely confident and committed to the premise that these four people you chose are the scum. A townie needs to keep a more open mind than that. Develop your reads more and acknowledge the possibility that you might be wrong. You have not solved the game, no need to be cocky.
But was the conclusion that you drew from it though right??Sure but that's not what you said lol
But when I'm right did I not then solve the game??You seem extremely confident and committed to the premise that these four people you chose are the scum. A townie needs to keep a more open mind than that. Develop your reads more and acknowledge the possibility that you might be wrong. You have not solved the game, no need to be cocky.
If you are sus you are sus until proven you ain't sus then you no longer sus... pretty simple concept
My bad I misread, then she is the fourth.... and thats how you sovle the game..
If that's effort then I'm completely stumpedNo I haven't, but I'm in the process. I just don't think any of your posts have been helpful yet, so I don't appreciate you coming in and using your posts to criticize effort.
Again I'm only chucking Nutella in there dont actually think she is scum but if there is 4 right now she is suspect #4
Jarizok spent the whole of D1 mob baiting and you all bit...
Mikey has been read baiting Look At The Posts he has posted how many mention someone possibly being scum or town?
Dusk has been randomly throwing people under buses..
Nutella has been vote following
It's easy to come up with a reason for voting for anyone never let it fool you.... oh wait...
All anyone has done so far this day is talk about the beanstalk, nobody is climbing it..
Yes
Ahhh so you have solved the game?
No?
Well I guess my 8 post D1 aren't that bad...
Why?? Nope I got it right the first time...Why??It became evident to me that there was some sort of miscommunication here and it had nothing to do with Bissy performing bad under pressure at all, because I think Bissy actually stood out as super towny while in this scenario.
This reason for un-voting just seems so forced to me, it was evident to me that Bissy was performing fine under this scrutiny, to me it was an evident miscommunication here. and it just kind of leaves me witha sour taste.I mean there's nothing for me to really respond to this? Fair enough you are entitled to your opinion but of course I will disagree that it was forced. I've already said I felt he dealt bad under pressure, which I later didn't think he dealt bad with the pressure in a necessarily scummy way which is why I unvoted.
You are of course entitled to your opinion, but I have kinda said my piece on this so I'm not sure what further insight I can offer you here?I was just telling you what rubbed me the wrong way, the reasoning in here didn't feel right, I wasn't really looking for any type of response to this in particular, but I do want to know what you think of Chimpy atm.Ok, you had said earlier you wanted to have an in thread conversation with me so I assumed you did.
I still think he is slightly towny just cause of his lack of caring attitude which idt scum picks up, but that's very weak because it isn't a very good reason to town read someone.
Wby what's your read on him?After personally just interacting with you and kind of throwing at you what Andra just described, I find her read to be totally bologna. You seemingly reacted the complete opposite of how she described you as acting. Tonally this quote stuck out to me at first as horribly misguided. I wanted to put a ploy into action to see if she was full of it or not. Dusk you've passed and Andra has failed.yes! i did want to chat, I don't like the way he just ate up anyone who townreads him for little reasoning, Like I at least want to know why I catch townreads and, I will even debate if i agree with the reasoning or not lol. I find just eating up townreads suspect like that. His lack of caring attitude to me is NAI because, there are a lot of scum who try and play like that also and often get the free type of passes that he got. The fact that you acknowledge that it's a town read but not a very good one in that way is tonally pretty pure IMO.
So, I didn't have much time because I'm about to watch me some playoff hockey so I wanted to try a little gambit here. END result is a townread for you. Here's why...
]duskfall's style overall seems to be to aggressively jump on people who have any sort of a negative read on him, and then hop to the next person and forget about the first.
i think overall my strongest lean is towards dusk. EBP imploded a bit, though, and i wouldn't be actively opposed to a lynch there.
i'm willing to drop a vote on dusk for now and will watch how this plays out
##Vote Duskfall
##Vote andracass
Okay I *think* I put the whole exchange in spoilers if I did this correctly. Color coded some stuff in the spoilers (took out the original coloring of the quotes) so hopefully that all works out, with comments below.
This first part is unnatural because Dusk had commented within the last ten minutes. In a W/W pre-set up reaction test, this would be you signalling to him that you were starting it
This reasoning for scum-reading Dusk is awful. If that was the point of your reaction test on Dusk, then okay, but I don't think it was a very good reaction test.
This here by Dusk was the ultimate brush off a scumread move. I would think a more natural response to the crap you tried to use to read on him would be for him to call you out on it and tell you it is crap. Instead, he pulls out "you are entitled to your opinion".
This part, and the conversation that follows is weird in the context of a reaction test. Why did you feel like you needed to side-track the reaction test into something else and specifically say "I'm not looking for a reaction"?
So this is the part that really gets me. The whole point of your reaction test was to see how valid Andra's reasoning was... and then you townread Dusk based on Andra being wrong about Dusk's play? Like, you don't comment on how Dusk's reaction was townie (which was supposed to be the whole point of the reaction test?), you comment on how Andra is scum. Also, you discredit Andra's comments on Dusk's past play by using his current play. That just doesn't work. What you should have done is found the example Andra was talking about and argue why that particular play by Dusk didn't match up with what Andra said. The whole way you employed the reaction test and came to a conclusion was either not logically sound, or a set-up for W/W Dusk/Blink to drive today how you guys wanted.
Of course, I could be having some serious conf-bias, so I would like some people outside of myself, Dusk, or Blink to let me know what they think.
Sorry I should have been more specific
Why??I happen to think he could be scum.While I was catching up on reading last night I noticed something that sparked up a red flag, and I'd rather get the opportunity to converse with him in real time, it would hep me a lot more.It became evident to me that there was some sort of miscommunication here and it had nothing to do with Bissy performing bad under pressure at all, because I think Bissy actually stood out as super towny while in this scenario.I've scumread nutella all the way through stop misrepping me on that because I have not been inconsistent even slightly.
My progression on bissy changed because at first I thought they were dealing bad with my pressure they were scum. But after a while I learned they were just unused to and uncomfortable in this enviroment so I could them some slack and unvoted. Upon reflection their posting seemed town motivated, which gains them a town lean from me.
This reason for un-voting just seems so forced to me, it was evident to me that Bissy was performing fine under this scrutiny, to me it was an evident miscommunication here. and it just kind of leaves me witha sour taste.why does this seem like you're being to self aware =(I think there's a good chance they killed football because it helps drive a mislynch on me since he was one of the active people townreading me most, but maybe I am being bias? Tbh I kinda felt like scum were going to push hard for me today.I mean there's nothing for me to really respond to this? Fair enough you are entitled to your opinion but of course I will disagree that it was forced. I've already said I felt he dealt bad under pressure, which I later didn't think he dealt bad with the pressure in a necessarily scummy way which is why I unvoted.It became evident to me that there was some sort of miscommunication here and it had nothing to do with Bissy performing bad under pressure at all, because I think Bissy actually stood out as super towny while in this scenario.
This reason for un-voting just seems so forced to me, it was evident to me that Bissy was performing fine under this scrutiny, to me it was an evident miscommunication here. and it just kind of leaves me witha sour taste.
You are of course entitled to your opinion, but I have kinda said my piece on this so I'm not sure what further insight I can offer you here?I was just telling you what rubbed me the wrong way, the reasoning in here didn't feel right, I wasn't really looking for any type of response to this in particular, but I do want to know what you think of Chimpy atm.I mean there's nothing for me to really respond to this? Fair enough you are entitled to your opinion but of course I will disagree that it was forced. I've already said I felt he dealt bad under pressure, which I later didn't think he dealt bad with the pressure in a necessarily scummy way which is why I unvoted.
You are of course entitled to your opinion, but I have kinda said my piece on this so I'm not sure what further insight I can offer you here?Ok, you had said earlier you wanted to have an in thread conversation with me so I assumed you did.I was just telling you what rubbed me the wrong way, the reasoning in here didn't feel right, I wasn't really looking for any type of response to this in particular, but I do want to know what you think of Chimpy atm.
I still think he is slightly towny just cause of his lack of caring attitude which idt scum picks up, but that's very weak because it isn't a very good reason to town read someone.
Wby what's your read on him?After personally just interacting with you and kind of throwing at you what Andra just described, I find her read to be totally bologna. You seemingly reacted the complete opposite of how she described you as acting. Tonally this quote stuck out to me at first as horribly misguided. I wanted to put a ploy into action to see if she was full of it or not. Dusk you've passed and Andra has failed.yes! i did want to chat, I don't like the way he just ate up anyone who townreads him for little reasoning, Like I at least want to know why I catch townreads and, I will even debate if i agree with the reasoning or not lol. I find just eating up townreads suspect like that. His lack of caring attitude to me is NAI because, there are a lot of scum who try and play like that also and often get the free type of passes that he got. The fact that you acknowledge that it's a town read but not a very good one in that way is tonally pretty pure IMO.Ok, you had said earlier you wanted to have an in thread conversation with me so I assumed you did.
I still think he is slightly towny just cause of his lack of caring attitude which idt scum picks up, but that's very weak because it isn't a very good reason to town read someone.
Wby what's your read on him?
So, I didn't have much time because I'm about to watch me some playoff hockey so I wanted to try a little gambit here. END result is a townread for you. Here's why...
]duskfall's style overall seems to be to aggressively jump on people who have any sort of a negative read on him, and then hop to the next person and forget about the first.
i think overall my strongest lean is towards dusk. EBP imploded a bit, though, and i wouldn't be actively opposed to a lynch there.
i'm willing to drop a vote on dusk for now and will watch how this plays out
##Vote Duskfall
##Vote andracass
Okay I *think* I put the whole exchange in spoilers if I did this correctly. Color coded some stuff in the spoilers (took out the original coloring of the quotes) so hopefully that all works out, with comments below.
This first part is unnatural because Dusk had commented within the last ten minutes. In a W/W pre-set up reaction test, this would be you signalling to him that you were starting it
This reasoning for scum-reading Dusk is awful. If that was the point of your reaction test on Dusk, then okay, but I don't think it was a very good reaction test.
This here by Dusk was the ultimate brush off a scumread move. I would think a more natural response to the crap you tried to use to read on him would be for him to call you out on it and tell you it is crap. Instead, he pulls out "you are entitled to your opinion".
This part, and the conversation that follows is weird in the context of a reaction test. Why did you feel like you needed to side-track the reaction test into something else and specifically say "I'm not looking for a reaction"?
So this is the part that really gets me. The whole point of your reaction test was to see how valid Andra's reasoning was... and then you townread Dusk based on Andra being wrong about Dusk's play? Like, you don't comment on how Dusk's reaction was townie (which was supposed to be the whole point of the reaction test?), you comment on how Andra is scum. Also, you discredit Andra's comments on Dusk's past play by using his current play. That just doesn't work. What you should have done is found the example Andra was talking about and argue why that particular play by Dusk didn't match up with what Andra said. The whole way you employed the reaction test and came to a conclusion was either not logically sound, or a set-up for W/W Dusk/Blink to drive today how you guys wanted.
Of course, I could be having some serious conf-bias, so I would like some people outside of myself, Dusk, or Blink to let me know what they think.
....
That whole post means nothing
Your scumsenses? need a tissue..It's a mix. Earlier his aggressiveness twords bissy triggered some of my scumsenses, but then most players seemingly cleared him for being genuine because of his "not giving a hoot" attitude, which imo is the easieast route for scum to take in any given mafia game.
The last three posts i quoted are just like a big wtf for me because as i already said it's not helping ua try and figure out the game if he is town.
Jarizok
Dusk
Mikey
Are scum I'll lob Nutella in there also because it wouldn't hurt to
Originally Posted by JackShepard
