Gonna NKA off this, kinda forgot about this game for a little but I'm back nowOriginally Posted by Keldeo 1557013294 (#2139)Alright, here are my thoughts right now. I'm kind of lost and flip-flopping on the middle of this list still, I think I have too many scummy people and not enough strong townreads. Hoping Virt's lynch today will help sort people out - let's not get complacent, no matter his flip.
insomnia - solid town. Putting a lot of work in and generally displaying a solvey attitude. Look into him if and only if he stays alive and pushes hard over and over for things that turn out to be wrong (or if new information arises, etc.)
Raiden Mei - towny. A few things like not really backing up a lot of her reads and, if Virtuoso is mafia, giving Virtuoso an easy townlean rub me the wrong way, but looking at her posts as a whole, I just don't see a mafia motivation to post a lot of it...
Wildfire - towny? Need to see more from her, I think. She has a lot of fire about theories that are probably wrong, gun-to-head I don't think a mafia would be as open about being self-conscious as she did d1, and that makes me feel kind of good about her. (Hope you feel better soon, by the way.)
The Lukundo - I have him marked as towny but don't really remember why :s I thought his spats with Raiden and Andrew felt v/v-ish, but at the heart of it I think I'm basically volume clearing him, which is unwise because I know he can post a lot as mafia. If Virtuoso is mafia, I don't think they're partners because posting that a town is pocketing your partner (P#138) is a thought that wouldn't occur to mafia imo.
Michelle - towny?? I don't really know how to read Michelle, so I'm kind of sheeping Andrew - who said he also struggles to read her, haha. I like a lot of her observations and how she feels relaxed, but her pushback on the Virtuoso wagon and on insomnia throughout D1 and into today despite listing Virtuoso as scum seems like NAGL if he flips mafia; she was very charitable toward him D1.
Bunnelby - null to towny?? Not sure from his posts alone, he just feels very hedgey, which I would expect from either town or scum new to the forum format. Today, especially if Virtuoso is mafia, it feels like it would be a lot easier for him to just say like, "yeah, I agree with your case on Virtuoso" and vote him, but instead he's sticking to his kears read.
Insaner - null, not here
GreenCatKid - null? I don't remember a lot from him and I'm running out of time. He just feels pretty low-impact regardless of alignment.
Garden Gnome - scummy?? I like some of her questions to people because they feel solvey, and I also really dislike some of them because it feels like she's asking just to ask. Her reads, especially her jump from Virtuoso onto sheep d1 if Virtuoso is mafia, feel like she's being wishy-washy. I think I could buy insomnia's case about her and Virtuoso as a team.
leetic - scummy?? Early on I talked about him looking at things that just look bad, jumping on easy targets that way, and not actually going deep into analyzing and questioning people, and I think that still applies. Notably, voted on Virtuoso both days. idk, while there are points for and against and he just hasn't been here very much for me to get a strong read, it feels like he's coasting on having done analysis that looks good but isn't actually very inquisitive, so I come down on the scummy side.
kears123 - scummy?? I'm torn on kears because she's done a lot of stuff that looks bad, like evading questions, not giving reads, pushing on easy targets. I haven't looked into her meta but from spectating a couple games I agree that she often seems scummy as town.
Virtuoso - highest confidence scum read. Cased him in P#1099. I'm glad your audition went well, hope you get the scholarship!