Having 5 no posters is disheartening in all honesty =(
Guess we have vigs for a reason.
Having 5 no posters is disheartening in all honesty =(
Guess we have vigs for a reason.
Honestly?
i don't miss the Nick Cave team
because they can get cuddled as any alignment without too much backlash
kajot has remained cool, i was hard on kajot one game when they were town and they remained calm, explained why they were town, etc.
think they're doing that this game?
haven't really interacted with them
team chat is quiet af, thread is slow, just waiting for people to pick up the pace and for lowposters to post
Mendel hasn't really been reading recently, and disagrees with my Beck read. Sadly he has had to go to sleep, so I doubt I'll get any more from him any time soon. My other Teammates have stopped paying attention as well at the moment... But I'll be asking them... And sadly they all stopped paying attention around post 400.
Honestly? I would have been going after myself. I actually started in on Jake for less of a mistake then I made, and he turned out to be villa.Hey all I'm back. Sorry for ghosting. Something came up.
Yes, I was far more in depth there because the game was smaller, and I already had someone to focus on as a primary suspect. This game is both far faster and far more crowded than I am used to (or prepared for), so my normal strategy of trying to keep up with the thread while putting together a post in Google Doc, while ISOing, was causing me a headache. I have since been...persuaded... by Catgod and mendel to step back and focus more on general reads and what is currently going on rather then trying to keep a full read set-up on everyone. (would like to note I had 2 of the 3 wolves pinned in that game by the end of D1 before scheduling conflicts forced me to sub out.)
As such...
I believe that most, if not all, of the people on my wagon are there for good reasons, and the only real argument I have for them is said lack of experience at this speed and density.
From what I have seen I also have a town lean for Beck. I'm going to try to keep up with this pace and add my reads and insites as we go along. If anyone has questions for me please mention me in the post.
Oof
Ok
Why are they good reasons and not just easy ones?
First of all, My first few post add little to the game state, other then some gut reads from me and my team, including some meta reads. Then, I left a sentence incomplete in a post that is connected to someone people had suspicions on. This is particularly bad as in that same post I was scum leaning them, and the sentence seemed to be about to say 'but not really'. I then effectively followed this up by making one more reply to complete said sentence, and then ghosted (had to leave suddenly, but you couldn't have known that).
This chain of events would have me hounding the player until they came back, and would leave me hounding them until I felt comfortable with them, someone more suspicious came along, or they were voted out/ night killed. So I have no reason to fault anyone voting for me and leaving that vote there.
@Elephantality
would like you, upon seeing this, to list your team's most consensus townreads and suspicions
also we meta'd you from 2016 and had some concerns. can you describe on a macro level how you think you've changed as a town player over the last 4 years?
Suspicion on whom? I have only said that you felt Townie to me... This actually makes me feel less so...
I think Orange is scum as well. His posts are a bit empty, and I don't like his reads, mainly his Eric read. It feels to high for a read that I don't think can be determined as town with such few posts he has had. Feel he is relying too much on the team aspect.
Sorry, This was meant for Beck on an early post, forgot to quote.
@Newcomb amrock wants you to tell him what to think on zardo casing himself because amrock is highly confused
someone talk to me please ._.
hi punchy!
Also confused by it and possibly regretting everything
@KipperRed
sup
I was asked why I thought you and the others voting for me gave me a town lean on you. So I did.
Hi gang, so I am like super out of my element, I dont really understand how to properly do stuff, currently as of now i have no reads on anyone but thats pretty usual for me while playing mafia
But I mean, Hey, Hype Time, and If I'm alive d5 then I will try my best to bring my a-game
: )
Also Sorry, Hi Lissa
hmm.because they can get cuddled as any alignment without too much backlash
kajot has remained cool, i was hard on kajot one game when they were town and they remained calm, explained why they were town, etc.
think they're doing that this game?
haven't really interacted with them
team chat is quiet af, thread is slow, just waiting for people to pick up the pace and for lowposters to post
They could easily be able to stay calm as mafia as well though.
I think they are reacting to the pressure in a more or less expected manner than anything else? Not taking too much out of it.
yo @PunchyTheCat
what on earth does warm thread presence mean wrt sloth
@iaffr: Wisp and Jack feel Logic is town (meta). I've been experimenting with a new playstyle to try to increase my read accuracy. Yet from the top of my head, I think I've had a similar entrance to this game in 2016. I also have trimmed fluff from my play, because I felt it was a weakness. Most of my reads are my individual reads.
I am a bit lazy to go back but interactions surrounding 1v1s tend to be a far better read then actually reading them yourself.
I know it didn't last long but when I was 1v1ing Logic what points of interest occured from your guys POV?
Amrock and Beck became town reads while I was doing that but nothing else really happened.
was just wondering if you/your team had thoughts since you popped in like 2.5h ago and then didn't say anything else
Tell Wisp I said hi.
Hey man I appreciate your honesty about this and believe this is a townie thought!
Do you have any dead-end / null conclusions you would like to share?
Any thoughts will do, in positions like this your best bet is to communicate why you are going blank and what exactly you aren't sure of, then people can interact with you and you can form reads that way.
Well, you’re wrong.What's weird about it? He said he sometimes gets ahead of himself, so I wanted to see some example of this. Yet, I can't find it in the games he linked.
Reading the games, I can't seem to really have any reason to find you town here. (Can't find the example I wanted) I think you are being unfair towards Xalt and Beeboy. With Xalt, you you don't consider the possibility of him being newb town making a mistake. It makes sense after he didn't notice my post saying I'd go on break. With Beeboy, I still feel you jumped the gun there. I think he believes what he is saying about Logic, because I can agree that he was forcing things. My read on Logic is still developing.Because I was confident in my read and the time and sometimes just cannot help myself.
I also didn’t give away a whole lot, which seems to be what you’re suggesting. I can’t let sheep’s mischaracterization slide when I am so confident in Logic being a villager.
But I’m not going to spend my time trying to convince you otherwise at this point.
like good vibes
Mendel hasn't really been reading recently, and disagrees with my Beck read. Sadly he has had to go to sleep, so I doubt I'll get any more from him any time soon. My other Teammates have stopped paying attention as well at the moment... But I'll be asking them... And sadly they all stopped paying attention around post 400.
Honestly? I would have been going after myself. I actually started in on Jake for less of a mistake then I made, and he turned out to be villa.Hey all I'm back. Sorry for ghosting. Something came up.
Yes, I was far more in depth there because the game was smaller, and I already had someone to focus on as a primary suspect. This game is both far faster and far more crowded than I am used to (or prepared for), so my normal strategy of trying to keep up with the thread while putting together a post in Google Doc, while ISOing, was causing me a headache. I have since been...persuaded... by Catgod and mendel to step back and focus more on general reads and what is currently going on rather then trying to keep a full read set-up on everyone. (would like to note I had 2 of the 3 wolves pinned in that game by the end of D1 before scheduling conflicts forced me to sub out.)
As such...
I believe that most, if not all, of the people on my wagon are there for good reasons, and the only real argument I have for them is said lack of experience at this speed and density.
From what I have seen I also have a town lean for Beck. I'm going to try to keep up with this pace and add my reads and insites as we go along. If anyone has questions for me please mention me in the post.
fwiw I find this brand of self-reflection to be >rand scum
Oof
Ok
Why are they good reasons and not just easy ones?
First of all, My first few post add little to the game state, other then some gut reads from me and my team, including some meta reads. Then, I left a sentence incomplete in a post that is connected to someone people had suspicions on. This is particularly bad as in that same post I was scum leaning them, and the sentence seemed to be about to say 'but not really'. I then effectively followed this up by making one more reply to complete said sentence, and then ghosted (had to leave suddenly, but you couldn't have known that).
This chain of events would have me hounding the player until they came back, and would leave me hounding them until I felt comfortable with them, someone more suspicious came along, or they were voted out/ night killed. So I have no reason to fault anyone voting for me and leaving that vote there.
how tf did that end up in the middle of the quote
well if they flipped out or smth they'd be instalynchedhmm.because they can get cuddled as any alignment without too much backlash
kajot has remained cool, i was hard on kajot one game when they were town and they remained calm, explained why they were town, etc.
think they're doing that this game?
haven't really interacted with them
team chat is quiet af, thread is slow, just waiting for people to pick up the pace and for lowposters to post
They could easily be able to stay calm as mafia as well though.
I think they are reacting to the pressure in a more or less expected manner than anything else? Not taking too much out of it.
fwiw I find this brand of self-reflection to be >rand scum
this is a pretty wolfy postMendel hasn't really been reading recently, and disagrees with my Beck read. Sadly he has had to go to sleep, so I doubt I'll get any more from him any time soon. My other Teammates have stopped paying attention as well at the moment... But I'll be asking them... And sadly they all stopped paying attention around post 400.
Honestly? I would have been going after myself. I actually started in on Jake for less of a mistake then I made, and he turned out to be villa.Hey all I'm back. Sorry for ghosting. Something came up.
Yes, I was far more in depth there because the game was smaller, and I already had someone to focus on as a primary suspect. This game is both far faster and far more crowded than I am used to (or prepared for), so my normal strategy of trying to keep up with the thread while putting together a post in Google Doc, while ISOing, was causing me a headache. I have since been...persuaded... by Catgod and mendel to step back and focus more on general reads and what is currently going on rather then trying to keep a full read set-up on everyone. (would like to note I had 2 of the 3 wolves pinned in that game by the end of D1 before scheduling conflicts forced me to sub out.)
As such...
I believe that most, if not all, of the people on my wagon are there for good reasons, and the only real argument I have for them is said lack of experience at this speed and density.
From what I have seen I also have a town lean for Beck. I'm going to try to keep up with this pace and add my reads and insites as we go along. If anyone has questions for me please mention me in the post.
Oof
Ok
Why are they good reasons and not just easy ones?
First of all, My first few post add little to the game state, other then some gut reads from me and my team, including some meta reads. Then, I left a sentence incomplete in a post that is connected to someone people had suspicions on. This is particularly bad as in that same post I was scum leaning them, and the sentence seemed to be about to say 'but not really'. I then effectively followed this up by making one more reply to complete said sentence, and then ghosted (had to leave suddenly, but you couldn't have known that).
This chain of events would have me hounding the player until they came back, and would leave me hounding them until I felt comfortable with them, someone more suspicious came along, or they were voted out/ night killed. So I have no reason to fault anyone voting for me and leaving that vote there.
newcomb described it as feeling kinda yougotme.gif-y
no $%#! I'm relying too much on my team they're the only ones that have yet read the thread
##Vote PunchyTheCat
I'll swing back over at some point before too long
Oh... It must not have liked all of the layers or something. If you check the post, you were quoting iaafr there, who was quoting me from my previous game on the site.
is this the beginning of one of those annoying tunnels i can't get rid of
Alright just reread the thread because I hadn't been paying much attention and Centuries was gettin angry at me for it. Been pretty busy today so it was great to actually read.
Took me about an hour, Centuries and I had a great discussion I think we really worked out a couple reads.
Random thoughts dump:
We really like Logic, they takes and posts earlier on we agreed with and don't think come from a wolf. We also agree that SHR is probably a villager based on tone. This read was mostly from me but Centuries agreed with me too. We really don't like Beck. A lot of his earlier posts felt off to us like he wasn't taking a lot of stances. I want to ISO him later to make my read on him more firm.
We both don't like sloth and Ele but we don't think they're scum together. Sloth's opener was really gross and I haven't particularly liked any of their posts since. Ele I just dont like. Their reasoning on their SR on me is bull$%#! and I feel like they're not actually making an effort to read me. Zardoric is up in the air for us. He posted a lot of reads but is avoiding interacting with the thread which I don't really like. Centuries things he's fine.
I still think that Nanook is good, i don't think they post whatever the hell posts are in their ISO as scum. Too attention grabby. We really like Marshal as well however I'll always be paranoid he's scum no matter how much my logical brain tells me hes town lmao. I also like orange. I like Arete's take on me that he said and he just seems find overall. Not grabbing for control of the thread, just chill. Kinda the same with Punchy. I really like their vibes, they seem really chill. Me and Centuries like iaafr, their thoughts and mentions regarding their teammates we think come from town and we like their tone.
We like Mist, mostly based off meta. We like jiggly puff because of their tone, especially in their first couple posts. Felt really pure to me. Centuries really likes Lissa, they're kinda null for me, but honorable mention. We also like Xalt.
I don't really like Monstr. I can't really put my finger on it but I just get bad vibes. I don't really like how he asked me that question earlier and didn't follow it up with anymore thoughts or reads on me, seemed weird. Centuries and I talked about how he kept making thread reads but didn't go anywhere with them.
Erik is really pure. He is town. I'm pretty null on Kajot people wagoned them earlier but I still don't fully understand why. Beeboy is good. This is kinda a gutread. Centuries likes Fenrir but I'm null on them. Also pretty null on Duk, Transcend, Kipper, and Tom.
LockTown
US
Strong Town
Logic
EK
SHR
Marshal
Town
Mist
FJP
Orange
Xalt
iaafr
Nanook
Beeboy
Lissa
Fenrir
Punchy
Nulltown
Tom
Transcende
Kipper
Kajot
Nullscum
Duk
Zard
Scum
Beck
Ele
Sloth
Monstr
Overall that's where we're at right now.
I'm going to go play jackbox with the bois, if you want me to elaborate on anything just ping me I'll be happy to do so, I'll probably answer in the morning. I'm probably gonna try and sort out my nulls tomorrow as well.
.
they do this
this is newcomb's reaction to zardo
We’re a bit conflicted on Zord’s reply.
I understand you’re trying to disarm our suspicion, but I agree with Lissa and OB5 that it reads instead like you’ve been caught and you’re owning up to it to gain sympathy.
If you’re a villager and everything you’ve done was done by a villager, how can you conclude none of us are taking advantage of the situation you’ve found yourself in? I think you’re taking the oath of least resistance and calling us all villagers because it’s true, and you recognize you’ve been caught, so you’re reading the game accurately as anything else would cause too much tension.
Those are my thoughts IRT.
that would be some solid towncred let's hope it's true
opportunistic pop-ins ftw
Posting Permissions
Keyboard Shortcuts
Quote
Originally Posted by beeboy
