Page 2 of 28 FirstFirst 123412 ... LastLast
Results 51 to 100 of 1358

Thread: Not A Mafia Game Thread(13p)

  1. ISO #51
    Thread Analyst N1NJ4W4RR10R's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2018
    Location
    Australia, NSW
    Posts
    200
    Timezone
    UTC+09:30
    Community
    Smirk Nation, previously Supercell Forums
    AKA
    Ninja
    Pronouns
    he/him/his/his/himself
    Gender
    Checking in.

    Don't pay much attention to spelling mistakes. Haven't gotten the PC set up yet so typing on mobile :s

    Quote Originally Posted by ImjustaDude (#38)
    We know it’s a VT heavy game, so maybe around 4-6 VT and 3-5 PR?

    A mafia goon if I recall is also considered vanilla. So maybe a goon and 2 Maf PRs.

    Just a rough thought process
    I'd say you're probably about right with your speculation. But no real point discussing set up at this point. No real benefits for the trade off of potentially having PRs slip and expose themselves.

    Quote Originally Posted by GhostCat (#49)
    And Pol and NASA are somewhere in the middle of their night, it’s daytime for Ninja. But unless Brandon started suddenly attending Sunday service, why hasn’t he posted yet? And Alpha.

    @FaisMX @JDS
    Gotta change my time zones, 30 mins behind the one on my profile now :P

    Anyways. Maf is always one of me, stitch and kart. I'm not maf, kart isn't playing, so logically stitch is maf.
    This has no relation to him stealing my totally original idea.

    ##Vote Stitch07

  2. ISO #52
    Thread Analyst ImjustaDude's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2020
    Posts
    260
    Timezone
    UTC-05:00
    Community
    Smirk Nation
    AKA
    Dude
    Gender
    Ok I see your point Snooks and Ninja. I’ll definitely keep that in mind.

    Ninja, how do you feel about SF’s post on Rad? Any takeaways?

  3. ISO #53
    Soul Reader Radiate's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2017
    Location
    United States
    Posts
    1,156
    Community
    The TvM Hub
    Gender
    "Watch me stand in the line,
    You're only serving lies,
    You've got something to hide,
    We gon' burn the whole house down" -- Burn the House Down by AJR

    Hi, I'm here to deliver on what iPromise(d). (You get a cookie if you get the reference.)

    ##Vote GhostCat for reasons that will be explained below:

    Quote Originally Posted by GhostCat (#8)
    What do you mean you can’t RV like you used to?
    Quote Originally Posted by GhostCat (#17)
    I like that forums are slower than Discord, but without the one-minute delay I thought there’d be more chatter, lol.

    Yes, Daisy, that’s what they’re replacing NL with, I guess.
    I don't really get these posts. A first glance shows that they're fluff, but it really feels like Snooks is just asking questions for the sake of asking questions. This indicates a scum mentality; town usually will ask questions that either advance town agenda, clarify some clear misunderstanding within a substantive argument, etc. Asking seemingly random questions and making non-confrontational remarks in the face of these responses fits into an agenda of making it seem like you're doing more than you actually are--a classic scum agenda.

    Quote Originally Posted by GhostCat (#20)
    I’d ask you why you voted Jim, but.... Eh. *Is there any reason?
    I really just don't understand why you don't care about why people vote a certain way. Like, not asking about it is eh, but flat out acknowledging it and showing apathy towards it is noncommittal.

    All of this is consistent with scum!Snooks meta, if I'm not mistaken, though it's been so long that I really can't be bothered to use meta as a main argument.

    I'll also address this:
    Quote Originally Posted by SilverFlute (#43)
    @DaisyCloud
    You see, someone who really intends to do "get the ball rolling" just goes ahead and does it, rather than making an announcement prior to The Event. It seems like trying too hard to get a double dose of credit. Tbh it reminds me of politicians gearing up for election-- "here's the problem, and here's what I'm going to do about it!"-- a typical popularity-winning tactic. He doesn't talk about how all the players can work together to change the standard, oh no-- it's a very deliberate narrative of how only Rad can save us from ourselves.

    Then there's Rad's vote against Brandon. He jokes around with his reasoning, which is a welcome bit of fun-- but it leaves me wondering if Rad would've placed his vote there if Stitch hadn't already placed the first. I wonder if he wants to distract from the fact he's BWing by dressing it up as his own independent 'joke reason'.

    Plus, voting against Rad, an experienced and active MU player, is more likely to lead interesting places than voting against someone who's newer/less active.

    It's not much, but it's not random.
    You're overextending: I wanted to get some work done before typing some stuff up. I take forever to write posts on forum mafia, and this is no exception. Whenever I played on Discord mafia, I just spammed the channel as much as I wanted to, and to be honest I didn't really put that much effort in as a result.

    So yeah, here's what all that waiting got you. I'm so, so sorry for the inconvenience. You must have been waiting forever. (insert some more passive-aggressive quibbles about waiting, et cetera, et cetera...)

  4. ISO #54
    Soul Reader DaisyCloud's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2017
    Posts
    1,620
    Community
    TvM Hub, FFS, SmirkNation
    Pronouns
    she/her/her/hers/herself
    Gender
    Quote Originally Posted by SilverFlute (#43)
    @DaisyCloud Yep, there's reasoning (: (hm, am really not enjoying this forum's semi-hideous emotes)

    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#29)
    I'm gonna wait a couple more hours before I get the ball rolling. There's been too many games where half of D1 gets thrown away because people just don't do anything. I'm determined to change that this game.
    You see, someone who really intends to do "get the ball rolling" just goes ahead and does it, rather than making an announcement prior to The Event. It seems like trying too hard to get a double dose of credit. Tbh it reminds me of politicians gearing up for election-- "here's the problem, and here's what I'm going to do about it!"-- a typical popularity-winning tactic. He doesn't talk about how all the players can work together to change the standard, oh no-- it's a very deliberate narrative of how only Rad can save us from ourselves.

    Then there's Rad's vote against Brandon. He jokes around with his reasoning, which is a welcome bit of fun-- but it leaves me wondering if Rad would've placed his vote there if Stitch hadn't already placed the first. I wonder if he wants to distract from the fact he's BWing by dressing it up as his own independent 'joke reason'.

    Plus, voting against Rad, an experienced and active MU player, is more likely to lead interesting places than voting against someone who's newer/less active.

    It's not much, but it's not random.
    ah, okay I see what you are saying. that is true most just do then say if they plan on leadership or something.

    I think it's still too early and not NAI. I will make a note of it though and see how things go.

  5. ISO #55
    Soul Reader Radiate's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2017
    Location
    United States
    Posts
    1,156
    Community
    The TvM Hub
    Gender
    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#54)
    I think it's still too early and not NAI.
    If you think that it's not NAI, do you think it's towny or scummy?

  6. ISO #56
    Thread Analyst N1NJ4W4RR10R's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2018
    Location
    Australia, NSW
    Posts
    200
    Timezone
    UTC+09:30
    Community
    Smirk Nation, previously Supercell Forums
    AKA
    Ninja
    Pronouns
    he/him/his/his/himself
    Gender
    Quote Originally Posted by ImjustaDude (#52)
    Ok I see your point Snooks and Ninja. I’ll definitely keep that in mind.

    Ninja, how do you feel about SF’s post on Rad? Any takeaways?
    Valid logic, but felt like she was trying to hard to make something of it. In fairness though it's early day 1 and "trying to hard to make something of it" is how you get discussion, reactions etc - so I'm not overly bothered by it.

    Did feel a bit fluffed up, but I'd be a hypocrite to use that as a negative.

  7. ISO #57
    Soul Reader DaisyCloud's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2017
    Posts
    1,620
    Community
    TvM Hub, FFS, SmirkNation
    Pronouns
    she/her/her/hers/herself
    Gender
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#55)
    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#54)
    I think it's still too early and not NAI.
    If you think that it's not NAI, do you think it's towny or scummy?
    NAI= not alignment indicative

    so, I think it's not alignment indicative because it's not alignment indicative.

  8. ISO #58
    Soul Reader Radiate's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2017
    Location
    United States
    Posts
    1,156
    Community
    The TvM Hub
    Gender
    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#57)
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#55)
    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#54)
    I think it's still too early and not NAI.
    If you think that it's not NAI, do you think it's towny or scummy?
    NAI= not alignment indicative

    so, I think it's not alignment indicative because it's not alignment indicative.
    Not NAI -> Not Not Alignment Indicative -> Alignment Indicative.

    Can I get your thoughts on Ninja and TD, the only other two people who have done anything remotely substantial this game?

  9. ISO #59
    Soul Reader DaisyCloud's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2017
    Posts
    1,620
    Community
    TvM Hub, FFS, SmirkNation
    Pronouns
    she/her/her/hers/herself
    Gender
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#53)
    "Watch me stand in the line,
    You're only serving lies,
    You've got something to hide,
    We gon' burn the whole house down" -- Burn the House Down by AJR

    Hi, I'm here to deliver on what iPromise(d). (You get a cookie if you get the reference.)

    ##Vote GhostCat for reasons that will be explained below:

    Quote Originally Posted by GhostCat (#8)
    What do you mean you can’t RV like you used to?
    Quote Originally Posted by GhostCat (#17)
    I like that forums are slower than Discord, but without the one-minute delay I thought there’d be more chatter, lol.

    Yes, Daisy, that’s what they’re replacing NL with, I guess.
    I don't really get these posts. A first glance shows that they're fluff, but it really feels like Snooks is just asking questions for the sake of asking questions. This indicates a scum mentality; town usually will ask questions that either advance town agenda, clarify some clear misunderstanding within a substantive argument, etc. Asking seemingly random questions and making non-confrontational remarks in the face of these responses fits into an agenda of making it seem like you're doing more than you actually are--a classic scum agenda.

    Quote Originally Posted by GhostCat (#20)
    I’d ask you why you voted Jim, but.... Eh. *Is there any reason?
    I really just don't understand why you don't care about why people vote a certain way. Like, not asking about it is eh, but flat out acknowledging it and showing apathy towards it is noncommittal.

    All of this is consistent with scum!Snooks meta, if I'm not mistaken, though it's been so long that I really can't be bothered to use meta as a main argument.

    I'll also address this:
    Quote Originally Posted by SilverFlute (#43)
    @DaisyCloud
    You see, someone who really intends to do "get the ball rolling" just goes ahead and does it, rather than making an announcement prior to The Event. It seems like trying too hard to get a double dose of credit. Tbh it reminds me of politicians gearing up for election-- "here's the problem, and here's what I'm going to do about it!"-- a typical popularity-winning tactic. He doesn't talk about how all the players can work together to change the standard, oh no-- it's a very deliberate narrative of how only Rad can save us from ourselves.

    Then there's Rad's vote against Brandon. He jokes around with his reasoning, which is a welcome bit of fun-- but it leaves me wondering if Rad would've placed his vote there if Stitch hadn't already placed the first. I wonder if he wants to distract from the fact he's BWing by dressing it up as his own independent 'joke reason'.

    Plus, voting against Rad, an experienced and active MU player, is more likely to lead interesting places than voting against someone who's newer/less active.

    It's not much, but it's not random.
    You're overextending: I wanted to get some work done before typing some stuff up. I take forever to write posts on forum mafia, and this is no exception. Whenever I played on Discord mafia, I just spammed the channel as much as I wanted to, and to be honest I didn't really put that much effort in as a result.

    So yeah, here's what all that waiting got you. I'm so, so sorry for the inconvenience. You must have been waiting forever. (insert some more passive-aggressive quibbles about waiting, et cetera, et cetera...)
    idk, snooks takes some time to warm up. and yeah if all she does posts like these that be something. think it's a bit too early.

    oh, and as too your comments to sf. hmm, maybe. not how I interpreted it.

    I gotta think on things and I'll just let this all stew.


    do you think you're being like a politician or more of a military general? yes it's an odd question but it's game related in a sense. wanna know how you gonna play this game.

  10. ISO #60
    Soul Reader DaisyCloud's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2017
    Posts
    1,620
    Community
    TvM Hub, FFS, SmirkNation
    Pronouns
    she/her/her/hers/herself
    Gender
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#58)
    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#57)
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#55)
    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#54)
    I think it's still too early and not NAI.
    If you think that it's not NAI, do you think it's towny or scummy?
    NAI= not alignment indicative

    so, I think it's not alignment indicative because it's not alignment indicative.
    Not NAI -> Not Not Alignment Indicative -> Alignment Indicative.

    Can I get your thoughts on Ninja and TD, the only other two people who have done anything remotely substantial this game?
    bro like I put an extra not there. my bad I had to read it 4x to see why you are pressing the issue.

    edit by way of post: it's NAI.

    i repeat it's just simply NAI.

  11. ISO #61
    Soul Reader Radiate's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2017
    Location
    United States
    Posts
    1,156
    Community
    The TvM Hub
    Gender
    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#60)
    bro like I put an extra not there. my bad I had to read it 4x to see why you are pressing the issue.

    edit by way of post: it's NAI.

    i repeat it's just simply NAI.
    Answer the question.

  12. ISO #62
    Soul Reader DaisyCloud's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2017
    Posts
    1,620
    Community
    TvM Hub, FFS, SmirkNation
    Pronouns
    she/her/her/hers/herself
    Gender
    I haven't played a game with either one of them in ages.

    ninja coming in stronk with his big post but it's not alot of content. him jk voting on stitch, iirc something like that, he does sometimes regardless of his alignment.

    we did play a game here in MU and he was nafoa and I was town. his style was a bit different. think forums does that.. so it was harder to pin him down. by the time I did most was sure they had the wolves pinned down and him and his team won. my point, he be someone to watch. not shading or anything.

    far as DUDE goes. I got no clue tbph. I don't remember any of our past games. gonna place him pretty much as new player, can't read etc, you know what I mean?

    Dude's post seem fine tho.

  13. ISO #63
    Soul Reader Radiate's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2017
    Location
    United States
    Posts
    1,156
    Community
    The TvM Hub
    Gender
    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#62)
    I haven't played a game with either one of them in ages.

    ninja coming in stronk with his big post but it's not alot of content. him jk voting on stitch, iirc something like that, he does sometimes regardless of his alignment.

    we did play a game here in MU and he was nafoa and I was town. his style was a bit different. think forums does that.. so it was harder to pin him down. by the time I did most was sure they had the wolves pinned down and him and his team won. my point, he be someone to watch. not shading or anything.

    far as DUDE goes. I got no clue tbph. I don't remember any of our past games. gonna place him pretty much as new player, can't read etc, you know what I mean?

    Dude's post seem fine tho.
    Dude was from like 2015-16 era mafia.

    I'd like Dude and Ninja to also give their thoughts on Stitch, Snooks, and Daisy (if they haven't already).

  14. ISO #64
    Soul Reader DaisyCloud's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2017
    Posts
    1,620
    Community
    TvM Hub, FFS, SmirkNation
    Pronouns
    she/her/her/hers/herself
    Gender
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#29)
    I'm gonna wait a couple more hours before I get the ball rolling. There's been too many games where half of D1 gets thrown away because people just don't do anything. I'm determined to change that this game.
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#55)
    If you think that it's not NAI, do you think it's towny or scummy?
    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#60)
    bro like I put an extra not there. my bad I had to read it 4x to see why you are pressing the issue.

    edit by way of post: it's NAI.

    i repeat it's just simply NAI.
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#61)
    Answer the question.
    okay okay. not sure why you are pressing the issue. I made an error in my sentence. ot happens.

    apparently you think it should have signicsmce. let's see.




    you want to wait, before you get things going. okay that's fine.. seems more like a checking in type statement.
    several players haven't even posted yet.

    your comment about day 1 being wasted. yeah, that happens. so just stating the obvious.

    you plan on changing how this game is gonna go compared to past games. you don't say how. change is just change . could be bad could be good. who knows. gotta wait and see. could help town could help mafia who knows.

    I can't read this as coming from a mafia or a town. either alignment could post this.

    now it came from you Rad. Rad has literally made promises he can't keep regardless of his alignment. This post I can see Rad making as town.I can see Rad as mafia posting something like this too. so I can see Rad posting this mafia and as town.

    Now him pressing to choose an alignment for this post... iirc he played something similarly in another game, he was town and so was I. he randed masons with another player and I was vig. my point, him pressing me and making me answer this over and over again. that seems to go with more of Rad's town methods then his mafia. but idk.

    how am I supposed to assign that post as towny or scummy? it's null.

  15. ISO #65
    Soul Reader DaisyCloud's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2017
    Posts
    1,620
    Community
    TvM Hub, FFS, SmirkNation
    Pronouns
    she/her/her/hers/herself
    Gender
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#63)
    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#62)
    I haven't played a game with either one of them in ages.

    ninja coming in stronk with his big post but it's not alot of content. him jk voting on stitch, iirc something like that, he does sometimes regardless of his alignment.

    we did play a game here in MU and he was nafoa and I was town. his style was a bit different. think forums does that.. so it was harder to pin him down. by the time I did most was sure they had the wolves pinned down and him and his team won. my point, he be someone to watch. not shading or anything.

    far as DUDE goes. I got no clue tbph. I don't remember any of our past games. gonna place him pretty much as new player, can't read etc, you know what I mean?

    Dude's post seem fine tho.
    Dude was from like 2015-16 era mafia.

    I'd like Dude and Ninja to also give their thoughts on Stitch, Snooks, and Daisy (if they haven't already).
    I didn't mean new as him being a newb. but new as in never played a game with him before, even tho I have. as in i got no meta.

  16. ISO #66
    Soul Reader DaisyCloud's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2017
    Posts
    1,620
    Community
    TvM Hub, FFS, SmirkNation
    Pronouns
    she/her/her/hers/herself
    Gender
    @Radiate what are your thoughts on Ninja, Dude, and Stitch?

  17. ISO #67
    Soul Reader DaisyCloud's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2017
    Posts
    1,620
    Community
    TvM Hub, FFS, SmirkNation
    Pronouns
    she/her/her/hers/herself
    Gender
    huh, I'm sitting here pressing reload to see if Rad has anything to say or is gonna answer any of my questions. looks like not.

    I feel like an idiot.

  18. ISO #68
    Soul Reader Radiate's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2017
    Location
    United States
    Posts
    1,156
    Community
    The TvM Hub
    Gender
    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#66)
    @Radiate what are your thoughts on Ninja, Dude, and Stitch?
    Stitch's opening is blatantly bad. I could (and will probably in the near future) push it, but I don't want to advance too many points simultaneously.

    TD's opening is null, as is Ninja's.

  19. ISO #69
    Soul Reader Radiate's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2017
    Location
    United States
    Posts
    1,156
    Community
    The TvM Hub
    Gender
    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#67)
    huh, I'm sitting here pressing reload to see if Rad has anything to say or is gonna answer any of my questions. looks like not.

    I feel like an idiot.
    this is perhaps the biggest bruh moment of all time

  20. ISO #70
    Thread Analyst ImjustaDude's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2020
    Posts
    260
    Timezone
    UTC-05:00
    Community
    Smirk Nation
    AKA
    Dude
    Gender
    Now this is starting to get interesting.

    Snooks asking many questions but adding no new original information is good enough to be suspicious but I do not think it is AI (At this stage at least). I wanna hear what Snooks has to say in response to this.

    As for stitch, it might be a reach but this post below might be townish behavior:

    Quote Originally Posted by Stitch07 (#35)
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#29)
    I'm gonna wait a couple more hours before I get the ball rolling. There's been too many games where half of D1 gets thrown away because people just don't do anything. I'm determined to change that this game.
    Sitting back and doing nothing sounds pretty good tbh. I'm down, ty Rad.
    Townies are more likely to be carefree unlike scum who would rather want to look 100% townie in the early stages of the game. Mafia are more likely to get straight into business instead of fooling around above.

    Ninja so far I need more time to see where he’s at.

    I’ll make a separate post about Daisy soon.

  21. ISO #71
    Automatic Game Mod Mafia Host's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2015
    Posts
    244,267
    Community
    Mafia Universe
    Not A Mafia Game Day 1 Votecount

    Votes Target Voters (Posts in Phase)
    1 J1M808 ImjustaDude (10)
    1 FaisMX Stitch07 (3)
    1 Sleep CometSmudge (2)
    1 Radiate SilverFlute (4)
    1 Stitch07 N1NJ4W4RR10R (2)
    1 GhostCat Radiate (12)
    7 Not voting JDS (0), GhostCat (13), Polarity (0), J1M808 (1), NASAGeek (0), DaisyCloud (14), FaisMX (0)


    View Vote History

    End day at majority is enabled. With 13 players alive, it takes 7 votes to reach majority.

    Day 1 ends at 12:00 PM EDT on Tuesday, July 21st, 2020. There are 1595347260000 remaining.

    Posted at 1 days, 15 hours, 12 minutes, 59 seconds remaining.

  22. ISO #72
    Soul Reader Radiate's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2017
    Location
    United States
    Posts
    1,156
    Community
    The TvM Hub
    Gender
    Quote Originally Posted by ImjustaDude (#70)
    Townies are more likely to be carefree unlike scum who would rather want to look 100% townie in the early stages of the game. Mafia are more likely to get straight into business instead of fooling around above.

    Ninja so far I need more time to see where he’s at.

    I’ll make a separate post about Daisy soon.
    If the norm for games is to not get anything started until 24+ hours into D1, and that norm helps scum more than town, wouldn't scum not want to do anything serious?

  23. ISO #73
    Thread Analyst ImjustaDude's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2020
    Posts
    260
    Timezone
    UTC-05:00
    Community
    Smirk Nation
    AKA
    Dude
    Gender
    DAISY: One scummy post isn’t grounds for an SR, but definetly something to look at. I say she’s nullscum.


    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#64)
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#29)
    I'm gonna wait a couple more hours before I get the ball rolling. There's been too many games where half of D1 gets thrown away because people just don't do anything. I'm determined to change that this game.
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#55)
    If you think that it's not NAI, do you think it's towny or scummy?
    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#60)
    bro like I put an extra not there. my bad I had to read it 4x to see why you are pressing the issue.

    edit by way of post: it's NAI.

    i repeat it's just simply NAI.
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#61)
    Answer the question.
    okay okay. not sure why you are pressing the issue. I made an error in my sentence. ot happens.

    apparently you think it should have signicsmce. let's see.




    you want to wait, before you get things going. okay that's fine.. seems more like a checking in type statement.
    several players haven't even posted yet.

    your comment about day 1 being wasted. yeah, that happens. so just stating the obvious.

    you plan on changing how this game is gonna go compared to past games. you don't say how. change is just change . could be bad could be good. who knows. gotta wait and see. could help town could help mafia who knows.

    I can't read this as coming from a mafia or a town. either alignment could post this.

    now it came from you Rad. Rad has literally made promises he can't keep regardless of his alignment. This post I can see Rad making as town.I can see Rad as mafia posting something like this too. so I can see Rad posting this mafia and as town.

    Now him pressing to choose an alignment for this post... iirc he played something similarly in another game, he was town and so was I. he randed masons with another player and I was vig. my point, him pressing me and making me answer this over and over again. that seems to go with more of Rad's town methods then his mafia. but idk.

    how am I supposed to assign that post as towny or scummy? it's null.
    #64 definitely raises some eyebrows from me. There is some slight shade thrown at Rad in bold. To me, it looks like indirect attacks that try to discredit their target. Not a fan of this post.

    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#62)
    I haven't played a game with either one of them in ages.

    ninja coming in stronk with his big post but it's not alot of content. him jk voting on stitch, iirc something like that, he does sometimes regardless of his alignment.

    we did play a game here in MU and he was nafoa and I was town. his style was a bit different. think forums does that.. so it was harder to pin him down. by the time I did most was sure they had the wolves pinned down and him and his team won. my point, he be someone to watch. not shading or anything.

    far as DUDE goes. I got no clue tbph. I don't remember any of our past games. gonna place him pretty much as new player, can't read etc, you know what I mean?

    Dude's post seem fine tho.
    I’ve never seen a Daisy town game from what I’ve seen so this post is Null.

    Also Daisy can you please clarify the bold? I’m assuming that fine posts= null from what I’m reading.

    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#72)
    If the norm for games is to not get anything started until 24+ hours into D1, and that norm helps scum more than town, wouldn't scum not want to do anything serious?
    You’re 100% right. Some scum definetly take advantage of the situation and mess around but others would likely want to stand out as early TRs (or at least not the scummiest looking player). It’s more of a gut feeling for me on stitch that I don’t know how to elaborate outside of that point.

  24. ISO #74
    Soul Reader Radiate's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2017
    Location
    United States
    Posts
    1,156
    Community
    The TvM Hub
    Gender
    "Life's like a road that you travel on,
    When there's on day here and the next day gone,
    Sometimes you bend, sometimes you stand,
    Sometime you turn your back to the wind" Rascal Flatts -- Life is a Highway

    Quote Originally Posted by ImjustaDude (#73)
    DAISY: One scummy post isn’t grounds for an SR, but definetly something to look at. I say she’s nullscum.


    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#64)
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#29)
    I'm gonna wait a couple more hours before I get the ball rolling. There's been too many games where half of D1 gets thrown away because people just don't do anything. I'm determined to change that this game.
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#55)
    If you think that it's not NAI, do you think it's towny or scummy?
    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#60)
    bro like I put an extra not there. my bad I had to read it 4x to see why you are pressing the issue.

    edit by way of post: it's NAI.

    i repeat it's just simply NAI.
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#61)
    Answer the question.
    okay okay. not sure why you are pressing the issue. I made an error in my sentence. ot happens.

    apparently you think it should have signicsmce. let's see.




    you want to wait, before you get things going. okay that's fine.. seems more like a checking in type statement.
    several players haven't even posted yet.

    your comment about day 1 being wasted. yeah, that happens. so just stating the obvious.

    you plan on changing how this game is gonna go compared to past games. you don't say how. change is just change . could be bad could be good. who knows. gotta wait and see. could help town could help mafia who knows.

    I can't read this as coming from a mafia or a town. either alignment could post this.

    now it came from you Rad. Rad has literally made promises he can't keep regardless of his alignment. This post I can see Rad making as town.I can see Rad as mafia posting something like this too. so I can see Rad posting this mafia and as town.

    Now him pressing to choose an alignment for this post... iirc he played something similarly in another game, he was town and so was I. he randed masons with another player and I was vig. my point, him pressing me and making me answer this over and over again. that seems to go with more of Rad's town methods then his mafia. but idk.

    how am I supposed to assign that post as towny or scummy? it's null.
    #64 definitely raises some eyebrows from me. There is some slight shade thrown at Rad in bold. To me, it looks like indirect attacks that try to discredit their target. Not a fan of this post.

    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#62)
    I haven't played a game with either one of them in ages.

    ninja coming in stronk with his big post but it's not alot of content. him jk voting on stitch, iirc something like that, he does sometimes regardless of his alignment.

    we did play a game here in MU and he was nafoa and I was town. his style was a bit different. think forums does that.. so it was harder to pin him down. by the time I did most was sure they had the wolves pinned down and him and his team won. my point, he be someone to watch. not shading or anything.

    far as DUDE goes. I got no clue tbph. I don't remember any of our past games. gonna place him pretty much as new player, can't read etc, you know what I mean?

    Dude's post seem fine tho.
    I’ve never seen a Daisy town game from what I’ve seen so this post is Null.

    Also Daisy can you please clarify the bold? I’m assuming that fine posts= null from what I’m reading.

    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#72)
    If the norm for games is to not get anything started until 24+ hours into D1, and that norm helps scum more than town, wouldn't scum not want to do anything serious?
    You’re 100% right. Some scum definetly take advantage of the situation and mess around but others would likely want to stand out as early TRs (or at least not the scummiest looking player). It’s more of a gut feeling for me on stitch that I don’t know how to elaborate outside of that point.
    I played with Daisy as town once. It was a Discord game, so any meta you could possibly glean from it is probably bunk. I'll circle back to my own thoughts on Daisy later though.

    I'm also gutreading Stitch but in the exact opposite direction as you.

    I still want to hear thoughts from Ninja, Stitch and Snooks.

    I don't know enough about timezones to know what the former two are doing. Snooks is probably doing mom things at this hour.

    While I still have you here Dude, how do you see Ninja progressing over D1?

  25. ISO #75
    Soul Reader DaisyCloud's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2017
    Posts
    1,620
    Community
    TvM Hub, FFS, SmirkNation
    Pronouns
    she/her/her/hers/herself
    Gender
    Quote Originally Posted by ImjustaDude (#73)
    DAISY: One scummy post isn’t grounds for an SR, but definetly something to look at. I say she’s nullscum.


    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#64)
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#29)
    I'm gonna wait a couple more hours before I get the ball rolling. There's been too many games where half of D1 gets thrown away because people just don't do anything. I'm determined to change that this game.
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#55)
    If you think that it's not NAI, do you think it's towny or scummy?
    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#60)
    bro like I put an extra not there. my bad I had to read it 4x to see why you are pressing the issue.

    edit by way of post: it's NAI.

    i repeat it's just simply NAI.
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#61)
    Answer the question.
    okay okay. not sure why you are pressing the issue. I made an error in my sentence. ot happens.

    apparently you think it should have signicsmce. let's see.




    you want to wait, before you get things going. okay that's fine.. seems more like a checking in type statement.
    several players haven't even posted yet.

    your comment about day 1 being wasted. yeah, that happens. so just stating the obvious.

    you plan on changing how this game is gonna go compared to past games. you don't say how. change is just change . could be bad could be good. who knows. gotta wait and see. could help town could help mafia who knows.

    I can't read this as coming from a mafia or a town. either alignment could post this.

    now it came from you Rad. Rad has literally made promises he can't keep regardless of his alignment. This post I can see Rad making as town.I can see Rad as mafia posting something like this too. so I can see Rad posting this mafia and as town.

    Now him pressing to choose an alignment for this post... iirc he played something similarly in another game, he was town and so was I. he randed masons with another player and I was vig. my point, him pressing me and making me answer this over and over again. that seems to go with more of Rad's town methods then his mafia. but idk.

    how am I supposed to assign that post as towny or scummy? it's null.
    #64 definitely raises some eyebrows from me. There is some slight shade thrown at Rad in bold. To me, it looks like indirect attacks that try to discredit their target. Not a fan of this post.

    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#62)
    I haven't played a game with either one of them in ages.

    ninja coming in stronk with his big post but it's not alot of content. him jk voting on stitch, iirc something like that, he does sometimes regardless of his alignment.

    we did play a game here in MU and he was nafoa and I was town. his style was a bit different. think forums does that.. so it was harder to pin him down. by the time I did most was sure they had the wolves pinned down and him and his team won. my point, he be someone to watch. not shading or anything.

    far as DUDE goes. I got no clue tbph. I don't remember any of our past games. gonna place him pretty much as new player, can't read etc, you know what I mean?

    Dude's post seem fine tho.
    I’ve never seen a Daisy town game from what I’ve seen so this post is Null.

    Also Daisy can you please clarify the bold? I’m assuming that fine posts= null from what I’m reading.

    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#72)
    If the norm for games is to not get anything started until 24+ hours into D1, and that norm helps scum more than town, wouldn't scum not want to do anything serious?
    You’re 100% right. Some scum definetly take advantage of the situation and mess around but others would likely want to stand out as early TRs (or at least not the scummiest looking player). It’s more of a gut feeling for me on stitch that I don’t know how to elaborate outside of that point.
    yes, I mean fine=bull


    I suppose I am throwing a bit if shade. he did like press me multiple times to answer that question. but nothing I said wasn't true facts or at least in how I remember in past games. plus I was being passive aggressive but it probably came as more aggressive idk idc idk why he kept wanting me to label the post as townie or scummy. idk he didn't accept me saying how I didn't mean to add an extra not.

    seems like that be something to post about more so then my responses.

    why do you think Rad kept asking me the same question over and over? how would you have responded in a similar situation? do you think knowing now that it was a bit weird at least to me that he kept on it, that maybe it changes the way you view how I made long post to answer his question in full and gave that short post of his my complete full and undivided attention? that idk maybe it's why I said the things I said in the way I said them? that just because I call Rad out on stuff that it isn't neccesarily shade? and even if it was shade that it isn't neccesarily scummy?

  26. ISO #76
    Soul Reader Radiate's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2017
    Location
    United States
    Posts
    1,156
    Community
    The TvM Hub
    Gender
    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#75)
    Quote Originally Posted by ImjustaDude (#73)
    DAISY: One scummy post isn’t grounds for an SR, but definetly something to look at. I say she’s nullscum.


    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#64)
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#29)
    I'm gonna wait a couple more hours before I get the ball rolling. There's been too many games where half of D1 gets thrown away because people just don't do anything. I'm determined to change that this game.
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#55)
    If you think that it's not NAI, do you think it's towny or scummy?
    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#60)
    bro like I put an extra not there. my bad I had to read it 4x to see why you are pressing the issue.

    edit by way of post: it's NAI.

    i repeat it's just simply NAI.
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#61)
    Answer the question.
    okay okay. not sure why you are pressing the issue. I made an error in my sentence. ot happens.

    apparently you think it should have signicsmce. let's see.




    you want to wait, before you get things going. okay that's fine.. seems more like a checking in type statement.
    several players haven't even posted yet.

    your comment about day 1 being wasted. yeah, that happens. so just stating the obvious.

    you plan on changing how this game is gonna go compared to past games. you don't say how. change is just change . could be bad could be good. who knows. gotta wait and see. could help town could help mafia who knows.

    I can't read this as coming from a mafia or a town. either alignment could post this.

    now it came from you Rad. Rad has literally made promises he can't keep regardless of his alignment. This post I can see Rad making as town.I can see Rad as mafia posting something like this too. so I can see Rad posting this mafia and as town.

    Now him pressing to choose an alignment for this post... iirc he played something similarly in another game, he was town and so was I. he randed masons with another player and I was vig. my point, him pressing me and making me answer this over and over again. that seems to go with more of Rad's town methods then his mafia. but idk.

    how am I supposed to assign that post as towny or scummy? it's null.
    #64 definitely raises some eyebrows from me. There is some slight shade thrown at Rad in bold. To me, it looks like indirect attacks that try to discredit their target. Not a fan of this post.

    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#62)
    I haven't played a game with either one of them in ages.

    ninja coming in stronk with his big post but it's not alot of content. him jk voting on stitch, iirc something like that, he does sometimes regardless of his alignment.

    we did play a game here in MU and he was nafoa and I was town. his style was a bit different. think forums does that.. so it was harder to pin him down. by the time I did most was sure they had the wolves pinned down and him and his team won. my point, he be someone to watch. not shading or anything.

    far as DUDE goes. I got no clue tbph. I don't remember any of our past games. gonna place him pretty much as new player, can't read etc, you know what I mean?

    Dude's post seem fine tho.
    I’ve never seen a Daisy town game from what I’ve seen so this post is Null.

    Also Daisy can you please clarify the bold? I’m assuming that fine posts= null from what I’m reading.

    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#72)
    If the norm for games is to not get anything started until 24+ hours into D1, and that norm helps scum more than town, wouldn't scum not want to do anything serious?
    You’re 100% right. Some scum definetly take advantage of the situation and mess around but others would likely want to stand out as early TRs (or at least not the scummiest looking player). It’s more of a gut feeling for me on stitch that I don’t know how to elaborate outside of that point.
    yes, I mean fine=bull


    I suppose I am throwing a bit if shade. he did like press me multiple times to answer that question. but nothing I said wasn't true facts or at least in how I remember in past games. plus I was being passive aggressive but it probably came as more aggressive idk idc idk why he kept wanting me to label the post as townie or scummy. idk he didn't accept me saying how I didn't mean to add an extra not.

    seems like that be something to post about more so then my responses.

    why do you think Rad kept asking me the same question over and over? how would you have responded in a similar situation? do you think knowing now that it was a bit weird at least to me that he kept on it, that maybe it changes the way you view how I made long post to answer his question in full and gave that short post of his my complete full and undivided attention? that idk maybe it's why I said the things I said in the way I said them? that just because I call Rad out on stuff that it isn't neccesarily shade? and even if it was shade that it isn't neccesarily scummy?
    Meh. It's water under the bridge. I take it that you're nullreading Dude at this point?

  27. ISO #77
    Soul Reader DaisyCloud's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2017
    Posts
    1,620
    Community
    TvM Hub, FFS, SmirkNation
    Pronouns
    she/her/her/hers/herself
    Gender
    null not bull. omg. edit is my friend. ;-;

  28. ISO #78
    Soul Reader DaisyCloud's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2017
    Posts
    1,620
    Community
    TvM Hub, FFS, SmirkNation
    Pronouns
    she/her/her/hers/herself
    Gender
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#76)
    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#75)
    Quote Originally Posted by ImjustaDude (#73)
    DAISY: One scummy post isn’t grounds for an SR, but definetly something to look at. I say she’s nullscum.


    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#64)
    If you think that it's not NAI, do you think it's towny or scummy?

    bro like I put an extra not there. my bad I had to read it 4x to see why you are pressing the issue.

    edit by way of post: it's NAI.

    i repeat it's just simply NAI.

    Answer the question.

    okay okay. not sure why you are pressing the issue. I made an error in my sentence. ot happens.

    apparently you think it should have signicsmce. let's see.




    you want to wait, before you get things going. okay that's fine.. seems more like a checking in type statement.
    several players haven't even posted yet.

    your comment about day 1 being wasted. yeah, that happens. so just stating the obvious.

    you plan on changing how this game is gonna go compared to past games. you don't say how. change is just change . could be bad could be good. who knows. gotta wait and see. could help town could help mafia who knows.

    I can't read this as coming from a mafia or a town. either alignment could post this.

    now it came from you Rad. Rad has literally made promises he can't keep regardless of his alignment. This post I can see Rad making as town.I can see Rad as mafia posting something like this too. so I can see Rad posting this mafia and as town.

    Now him pressing to choose an alignment for this post... iirc he played something similarly in another game, he was town and so was I. he randed masons with another player and I was vig. my point, him pressing me and making me answer this over and over again. that seems to go with more of Rad's town methods then his mafia. but idk.

    how am I supposed to assign that post as towny or scummy? it's null.
    #64 definitely raises some eyebrows from me. There is some slight shade thrown at Rad in bold. To me, it looks like indirect attacks that try to discredit their target. Not a fan of this post.

    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#62)
    I haven't played a game with either one of them in ages.

    ninja coming in stronk with his big post but it's not alot of content. him jk voting on stitch, iirc something like that, he does sometimes regardless of his alignment.

    we did play a game here in MU and he was nafoa and I was town. his style was a bit different. think forums does that.. so it was harder to pin him down. by the time I did most was sure they had the wolves pinned down and him and his team won. my point, he be someone to watch. not shading or anything.

    far as DUDE goes. I got no clue tbph. I don't remember any of our past games. gonna place him pretty much as new player, can't read etc, you know what I mean?

    Dude's post seem fine tho.
    I’ve never seen a Daisy town game from what I’ve seen so this post is Null.

    Also Daisy can you please clarify the bold? I’m assuming that fine posts= null from what I’m reading.

    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#72)
    If the norm for games is to not get anything started until 24+ hours into D1, and that norm helps scum more than town, wouldn't scum not want to do anything serious?
    You’re 100% right. Some scum definetly take advantage of the situation and mess around but others would likely want to stand out as early TRs (or at least not the scummiest looking player). It’s more of a gut feeling for me on stitch that I don’t know how to elaborate outside of that point.
    yes, I mean fine=bull


    I suppose I am throwing a bit if shade. he did like press me multiple times to answer that question. but nothing I said wasn't true facts or at least in how I remember in past games. plus I was being passive aggressive but it probably came as more aggressive idk idc idk why he kept wanting me to label the post as townie or scummy. idk he didn't accept me saying how I didn't mean to add an extra not.

    seems like that be something to post about more so then my responses.

    why do you think Rad kept asking me the same question over and over? how would you have responded in a similar situation? do you think knowing now that it was a bit weird at least to me that he kept on it, that maybe it changes the way you view how I made long post to answer his question in full and gave that short post of his my complete full and undivided attention? that idk maybe it's why I said the things I said in the way I said them? that just because I call Rad out on stuff that it isn't neccesarily shade? and even if it was shade that it isn't neccesarily scummy?
    Meh. It's water under the bridge. I take it that you're nullreading Dude at this point?
    there maybe a bridge but it's yet to be determined if it's water over or under it or if the bridge is burning or not.

    yes, so far this game everyone is in the null. but like some are closer to red and some closer to green.

  29. ISO #79
    Soul Reader Radiate's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2017
    Location
    United States
    Posts
    1,156
    Community
    The TvM Hub
    Gender
    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#78)
    yes, so far this game everyone is in the null. but like some are closer to red and some closer to green.
    Who's closer to red and who's closer to green? What you have described is everyone's early D1 readlist ever lmao

  30. ISO #80
    Bandwagoner GhostCat's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2017
    Location
    Canada
    Posts
    194
    Community
    Smirk Nation (Discord) — Formerly Supercell Forums
    AKA
    Snooks
    Pronouns
    she/her/her/hers/herself
    Gender
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#53)
    "Watch me stand in the line,
    You're only serving lies,
    You've got something to hide,
    We gon' burn the whole house down" -- Burn the House Down by AJR

    Hi, I'm here to deliver on what iPromise(d). (You get a cookie if you get the reference.)

    ##Vote GhostCat for reasons that will be explained below:

    Quote Originally Posted by GhostCat (#8)
    What do you mean you can’t RV like you used to?
    Quote Originally Posted by GhostCat (#17)
    I like that forums are slower than Discord, but without the one-minute delay I thought there’d be more chatter, lol.

    Yes, Daisy, that’s what they’re replacing NL with, I guess.
    I don't really get these posts. A first glance shows that they're fluff, but it really feels like Snooks is just asking questions for the sake of asking questions. This indicates a scum mentality; town usually will ask questions that either advance town agenda, clarify some clear misunderstanding within a substantive argument, etc. Asking seemingly random questions and making non-confrontational remarks in the face of these responses fits into an agenda of making it seem like you're doing more than you actually are--a classic scum agenda.

    Quote Originally Posted by GhostCat (#20)
    I’d ask you why you voted Jim, but.... Eh. *Is there any reason?
    I really just don't understand why you don't care about why people vote a certain way. Like, not asking about it is eh, but flat out acknowledging it and showing apathy towards it is noncommittal.

    All of this is consistent with scum!Snooks meta, if I'm not mistaken, though it's been so long that I really can't be bothered to use meta as a main argument.

    I'll also address this:
    Quote Originally Posted by SilverFlute (#43)
    @DaisyCloud
    You see, someone who really intends to do "get the ball rolling" just goes ahead and does it, rather than making an announcement prior to The Event. It seems like trying too hard to get a double dose of credit. Tbh it reminds me of politicians gearing up for election-- "here's the problem, and here's what I'm going to do about it!"-- a typical popularity-winning tactic. He doesn't talk about how all the players can work together to change the standard, oh no-- it's a very deliberate narrative of how only Rad can save us from ourselves.

    Then there's Rad's vote against Brandon. He jokes around with his reasoning, which is a welcome bit of fun-- but it leaves me wondering if Rad would've placed his vote there if Stitch hadn't already placed the first. I wonder if he wants to distract from the fact he's BWing by dressing it up as his own independent 'joke reason'.

    Plus, voting against Rad, an experienced and active MU player, is more likely to lead interesting places than voting against someone who's newer/less active.

    It's not much, but it's not random.
    You're overextending: I wanted to get some work done before typing some stuff up. I take forever to write posts on forum mafia, and this is no exception. Whenever I played on Discord mafia, I just spammed the channel as much as I wanted to, and to be honest I didn't really put that much effort in as a result.

    So yeah, here's what all that waiting got you. I'm so, so sorry for the inconvenience. You must have been waiting forever. (insert some more passive-aggressive quibbles about waiting, et cetera, et cetera...)
    Hmmmmm.

    You may or may not be surprised to find I have an issue with some of your points.

    (But first... Is that a quote from one of iPromise/you-know-who’s fave songs? Do I get a cookie?)

    So the first thing you did here (besides ignore the fact that Brandon hadn’t responded to you yet and when you said you weren’t going to let nothing get accomplished today and Stitch just responded with essentially an “ok, I’ll sit back and do nothing”—-which you seem to be ok with?) was to pick a couple of random starting posts of mine and basically say I’m asking questions for the sake of asking questions.

    Well... yes.

    I doubt it even counts as “fluff”. We were at the start of the game, nothing going on, so just chatting with the people who had posted thus far, trying to get some sort of conversation going.

    There hadn’t even *been any big “misunderstandings” to clarify or “substantive arguments” to take a stance on, or anything warranting a confrontational (as opposed to non-confrontational) response.

    And...asking about the vote but not caring why they voted, being apathetic? Don’t even try to misrepresent my motivations/intent here.

    It’s an RV at the start of the game, on someone who hadn’t even posted yet, iirc. What *reason is there for that vote? Dude random cotes.

    But I asked anyway just in case maybe he had something to say about playing with him years ago that might have sparked an interest in having a conversation with him, as opposed to a completely random thing.

    But, rng it was. As I suspected. It isn’t “apathy”. It’s just a “there’s nothing there yet”.

    So then you make a contradictory point, saying it’s been “so long” you don’t want to use meta as a main argument. While simultaneously stating it’s consistent with scum!Snooks meta and accusing me of having a “classic scum agenda”.

    So yeah, you’re trying to use meta as an argument. But the thing is we’ve played together and/or spectated games for years. It’s not like I’m some stranger you have no experience with. I’ve changed my meta about as often as Santa changes the colour of his hat.

    I’m rarely an aggressive player unless & until I have some urgent reason to be (or did you also forget the last game you hosted, too)? Yet you’re making it out as though town!Snooks *should be. So to accuse me, this early, of having some sort of “classic scum agenda” is a load of shady baloney, and a bright red flag.

    I initially thought Silver was “overextending” a bit, as well, in regards to you. (That was a lot of explanation for her vote that “wasn’t much”.) Basically valid points, yes, but like Dude said I felt it was a bit more NAI.) I asked Silver how much she played with you guys back on the forums, because I feel like you would likely vote Brandon even if Stitch hadn’t. It kind of feels like the expected opening in a game of chess, lol.

    But this *case? on me feels less like some sort of “reaction test” and more like a push to see who’ll go along with it. Because if you’re town, I don’t think you make it. You usually take a more “wait and see” approach with me. You’ve *legit scum-read/made statements against me before, and whatever this is, at this point in the game...isn’t anything like it.

    And... I have a lot to read back on.

  31. ISO #81
    Soul Reader DaisyCloud's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2017
    Posts
    1,620
    Community
    TvM Hub, FFS, SmirkNation
    Pronouns
    she/her/her/hers/herself
    Gender
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#79)
    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#78)
    yes, so far this game everyone is in the null. but like some are closer to red and some closer to green.
    Who's closer to red and who's closer to green? What you have described is everyone's early D1 readlist ever lmao
    oh no no no no

    I know what u want to know. just say it. why talk in circles like this?

    rad you seem more like your town games then your mafia games.

    in a scale of 1-10 with 1 being ultimate scum and 10 being the towniest town that there ever was the, goatest of goats. and 5 being true null.

    no posters= 0

    rad is 6

    sf is 6

    DUDE= 6

    comet= 5

    snooks= 5

    ninja= 5

    stitch= 4

    that is far as my last brain cell has been able to do. this is goat tier Daisy post right here if I do say do myself. I feel stronk on this.

  32. ISO #82
    Bandwagoner GhostCat's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2017
    Location
    Canada
    Posts
    194
    Community
    Smirk Nation (Discord) — Formerly Supercell Forums
    AKA
    Snooks
    Pronouns
    she/her/her/hers/herself
    Gender
    I also need to figure out how to condense the original quote, because that book is too much of a book, lol.

  33. ISO #83
    Soul Reader DaisyCloud's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2017
    Posts
    1,620
    Community
    TvM Hub, FFS, SmirkNation
    Pronouns
    she/her/her/hers/herself
    Gender
    wait no posters are not 0 they are 5. my bad.

  34. ISO #84
    Soul Reader Radiate's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2017
    Location
    United States
    Posts
    1,156
    Community
    The TvM Hub
    Gender
    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#81)
    that is far as my last brain cell has been able to do. this is goat tier Daisy post right here if I do say do myself. I feel stronk on this.
    are you okay

  35. ISO #85
    Soul Reader DaisyCloud's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2017
    Posts
    1,620
    Community
    TvM Hub, FFS, SmirkNation
    Pronouns
    she/her/her/hers/herself
    Gender
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#84)
    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#81)
    that is far as my last brain cell has been able to do. this is goat tier Daisy post right here if I do say do myself. I feel stronk on this.
    are you okay
    >.<

  36. ISO #86
    Soul Reader Radiate's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2017
    Location
    United States
    Posts
    1,156
    Community
    The TvM Hub
    Gender
    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#85)
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#84)
    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#81)
    that is far as my last brain cell has been able to do. this is goat tier Daisy post right here if I do say do myself. I feel stronk on this.
    are you okay
    >.<
    well if that ain't a mood

  37. ISO #87
    Soul Reader DaisyCloud's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2017
    Posts
    1,620
    Community
    TvM Hub, FFS, SmirkNation
    Pronouns
    she/her/her/hers/herself
    Gender
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#86)
    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#85)
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#84)
    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#81)
    that is far as my last brain cell has been able to do. this is goat tier Daisy post right here if I do say do myself. I feel stronk on this.
    are you okay
    >.<
    well if that ain't a mood
    jfxhixtziskjkl

  38. ISO #88
    Soul Reader Radiate's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2017
    Location
    United States
    Posts
    1,156
    Community
    The TvM Hub
    Gender
    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#87)
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#86)
    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#85)
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#84)
    are you okay
    >.<
    well if that ain't a mood
    jfxhixtziskjkl
    ok this is the part where i kindly ask you to stop spamming the thread.

    do you have anything else you'd like to share with the class

  39. ISO #89
    Soul Reader DaisyCloud's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2017
    Posts
    1,620
    Community
    TvM Hub, FFS, SmirkNation
    Pronouns
    she/her/her/hers/herself
    Gender
    Quote Originally Posted by GhostCat (#80)
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#53)
    "Watch me stand in the line,
    You're only serving lies,
    You've got something to hide,
    We gon' burn the whole house down" -- Burn the House Down by AJR

    Hi, I'm here to deliver on what iPromise(d). (You get a cookie if you get the reference.)

    ##Vote GhostCat for reasons that will be explained below:

    Quote Originally Posted by GhostCat (#8)
    What do you mean you can’t RV like you used to?
    Quote Originally Posted by GhostCat (#17)
    I like that forums are slower than Discord, but without the one-minute delay I thought there’d be more chatter, lol.

    Yes, Daisy, that’s what they’re replacing NL with, I guess.
    I don't really get these posts. A first glance shows that they're fluff, but it really feels like Snooks is just asking questions for the sake of asking questions. This indicates a scum mentality; town usually will ask questions that either advance town agenda, clarify some clear misunderstanding within a substantive argument, etc. Asking seemingly random questions and making non-confrontational remarks in the face of these responses fits into an agenda of making it seem like you're doing more than you actually are--a classic scum agenda.

    Quote Originally Posted by GhostCat (#20)
    I’d ask you why you voted Jim, but.... Eh. *Is there any reason?
    I really just don't understand why you don't care about why people vote a certain way. Like, not asking about it is eh, but flat out acknowledging it and showing apathy towards it is noncommittal.

    All of this is consistent with scum!Snooks meta, if I'm not mistaken, though it's been so long that I really can't be bothered to use meta as a main argument.

    I'll also address this:
    Quote Originally Posted by SilverFlute (#43)
    @DaisyCloud
    You see, someone who really intends to do "get the ball rolling" just goes ahead and does it, rather than making an announcement prior to The Event. It seems like trying too hard to get a double dose of credit. Tbh it reminds me of politicians gearing up for election-- "here's the problem, and here's what I'm going to do about it!"-- a typical popularity-winning tactic. He doesn't talk about how all the players can work together to change the standard, oh no-- it's a very deliberate narrative of how only Rad can save us from ourselves.

    Then there's Rad's vote against Brandon. He jokes around with his reasoning, which is a welcome bit of fun-- but it leaves me wondering if Rad would've placed his vote there if Stitch hadn't already placed the first. I wonder if he wants to distract from the fact he's BWing by dressing it up as his own independent 'joke reason'.

    Plus, voting against Rad, an experienced and active MU player, is more likely to lead interesting places than voting against someone who's newer/less active.

    It's not much, but it's not random.
    You're overextending: I wanted to get some work done before typing some stuff up. I take forever to write posts on forum mafia, and this is no exception. Whenever I played on Discord mafia, I just spammed the channel as much as I wanted to, and to be honest I didn't really put that much effort in as a result.

    So yeah, here's what all that waiting got you. I'm so, so sorry for the inconvenience. You must have been waiting forever. (insert some more passive-aggressive quibbles about waiting, et cetera, et cetera...)
    Quote Originally Posted by GhostCat (#80)

    Hmmmmm.

    You may or may not be surprised to find I have an issue with some of your points.

    (But first... Is that a quote from one of iPromise/you-know-who’s fave songs? Do I get a cookie?)

    So the first thing you did here (besides ignore the fact that Brandon hadn’t responded to you yet and when you said you weren’t going to let nothing get accomplished today and Stitch just responded with essentially an “ok, I’ll sit back and do nothing”—-which you seem to be ok with?) was to pick a couple of random starting posts of mine and basically say I’m asking questions for the sake of asking questions.

    Well... yes.

    I doubt it even counts as “fluff”. We were at the start of the game, nothing going on, so just chatting with the people who had posted thus far, trying to get some sort of conversation going.

    There hadn’t even *been any big “misunderstandings” to clarify or “substantive arguments” to take a stance on, or anything warranting a confrontational (as opposed to non-confrontational) response.

    And...asking about the vote but not caring why they voted, being apathetic? Don’t even try to misrepresent my motivations/intent here.

    It’s an RV at the start of the game, on someone who hadn’t even posted yet, iirc. What *reason is there for that vote? Dude random cotes.

    But I asked anyway just in case maybe he had something to say about playing with him years ago that might have sparked an interest in having a conversation with him, as opposed to a completely random thing.

    But, rng it was. As I suspected. It isn’t “apathy”. It’s just a “there’s nothing there yet”.

    So then you make a contradictory point, saying it’s been “so long” you don’t want to use meta as a main argument. While simultaneously stating it’s consistent with scum!Snooks meta and accusing me of having a “classic scum agenda”.

    So yeah, you’re trying to use meta as an argument. But the thing is we’ve played together and/or spectated games for years. It’s not like I’m some stranger you have no experience with. I’ve changed my meta about as often as Santa changes the colour of his hat.

    I’m rarely an aggressive player unless & until I have some urgent reason to be (or did you also forget the last game you hosted, too)? Yet you’re making it out as though town!Snooks *should be. So to accuse me, this early, of having some sort of “classic scum agenda” is a load of shady baloney, and a bright red flag.

    I initially thought Silver was “overextending” a bit, as well, in regards to you. (That was a lot of explanation for her vote that “wasn’t much”.) Basically valid points, yes, but like Dude said I felt it was a bit more NAI.) I asked Silver how much she played with you guys back on the forums, because I feel like you would likely vote Brandon even if Stitch hadn’t. It kind of feels like the expected opening in a game of chess, lol.

    But this *case? on me feels less like some sort of “reaction test” and more like a push to see who’ll go along with it. Because if you’re town, I don’t think you make it. You usually take a more “wait and see” approach with me. You’ve *legit scum-read/made statements against me before, and whatever this is, at this point in the game...isn’t anything like it.

    And... I have a lot to read back on.


    huh, okay originally I thought it was null the things DUDE said. but yeah it is a bit early to be making cases. and yeah retread it be weird to say no meta and then use meta.

    idk think your points is more valid the DUDE'S.

    I like your points and it seems more like town snooks. you are at 61/2 tho now. idk if that means anything to you.

    I look forward to more of your comments to things going on so far in game and look forward to your own say on things too.

  40. ISO #90
    Thread Analyst ImjustaDude's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2020
    Posts
    260
    Timezone
    UTC-05:00
    Community
    Smirk Nation
    AKA
    Dude
    Gender
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#74)
    While I still have you here Dude, how do you see Ninja progressing over D1?
    I expect him to post more and contribute which may lead to a TR. It all depends on how he acts from now till EOD.

  41. ISO #91
    Soul Reader DaisyCloud's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2017
    Posts
    1,620
    Community
    TvM Hub, FFS, SmirkNation
    Pronouns
    she/her/her/hers/herself
    Gender
    Quote Originally Posted by GhostCat (#82)
    I also need to figure out how to condense the original quote, because that book is too much of a book, lol.
    I use spoilers. I never did figure out the method to quote posts.

    put whatever inside the [] [/]

  42. ISO #92
    Soul Reader DaisyCloud's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2017
    Posts
    1,620
    Community
    TvM Hub, FFS, SmirkNation
    Pronouns
    she/her/her/hers/herself
    Gender
    edit by way of post:

    I never did figure out the postnum method to quote posts.

    [spoilers] [/spoilers] without the s tho

    and the postnum goes inside the brackets but idk what else because it never works for me.

  43. ISO #93
    Soul Reader DaisyCloud's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2017
    Posts
    1,620
    Community
    TvM Hub, FFS, SmirkNation
    Pronouns
    she/her/her/hers/herself
    Gender
    Quote Originally Posted by ImjustaDude (#90)
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#74)
    While I still have you here Dude, how do you see Ninja progressing over D1?
    I expect him to post more and contribute which may lead to a TR. It all depends on how he acts from now till EOD.
    I look forward to your reply to my response to you that you made about me. jsn

  44. ISO #94
    Soul Reader DaisyCloud's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2017
    Posts
    1,620
    Community
    TvM Hub, FFS, SmirkNation
    Pronouns
    she/her/her/hers/herself
    Gender
    also look forward to what snooks has to say about rad and his case on snooks.

  45. ISO #95
    Soul Reader DaisyCloud's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2017
    Posts
    1,620
    Community
    TvM Hub, FFS, SmirkNation
    Pronouns
    she/her/her/hers/herself
    Gender
    idk why I thought it was DUDE snooks was replying to. it was actually Rad.

  46. ISO #96
    Bandwagoner GhostCat's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2017
    Location
    Canada
    Posts
    194
    Community
    Smirk Nation (Discord) — Formerly Supercell Forums
    AKA
    Snooks
    Pronouns
    she/her/her/hers/herself
    Gender
    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#89)
    [spoiler]



    huh, okay originally I thought it was null the things DUDE said. but yeah it is a bit early to be making cases. and yeah retread it be weird to say no meta and then use meta.

    idk think your points is more valid the DUDE'S.

    I like your points and it seems more like town snooks. you are at 61/2 tho now. idk if that means anything to you.

    I look forward to more of your comments to things going on so far in game and look forward to your own say on things too.
    I’ve yes, been doing Mom things and will again for a bit soon. Also time for the almost regularly scheduled evening hailstorm. If I don’t post again in the next few hours, that may be why.

    But there are things to read now, though I’ve said what I’m most concerned about atm. Is there anyone else in specific you want me to comment on?

    Yeah, Rad’s pressing you on that wording about not NAI is town-Rad looking “behaviour” but it’s really kind of a weird thing to press someone on.

    Dude and Ninja doing substantial things. So far Dude wanted to talk about how many vanillas and PRs we have, and Ninja had the same kind of thoughts as I did about Silver’s post (as I was writing what turned out to be that wall.) I haven’t really made a “read” on them yet. But Idk that what they’ve done is “substantial”.

    And unless I missed it, Brandon and Alpha still haven’t chimed in on anything. I expect Pol and NASA to be in soon. So a third of the players aren’t even here yet. Stitch’s opening was kinda scummy, but eh...might have been waiting to see Rad’s response (and sleeping). He’ll have more to say soon.

    I expect to have a lot to read in the morning.

  47. ISO #97
    Soul Reader DaisyCloud's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2017
    Posts
    1,620
    Community
    TvM Hub, FFS, SmirkNation
    Pronouns
    she/her/her/hers/herself
    Gender
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#88)
    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#87)
    Quote Originally Posted by Radiate (#86)
    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#85)
    >.<
    well if that ain't a mood
    jfxhixtziskjkl
    ok this is the part where i kindly ask you to stop spamming the thread.

    do you have anything else you'd like to share with the class
    you just gonna go and make fun of me and ignore the whole other part to that post and act like there is something wrong in what I'm doing.

    k

    I see how it is

  48. ISO #98
    Thread Analyst ImjustaDude's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2020
    Posts
    260
    Timezone
    UTC-05:00
    Community
    Smirk Nation
    AKA
    Dude
    Gender
    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#75)

    yes, I mean fine=bull


    I suppose I am throwing a bit if shade. he did like press me multiple times to answer that question. but nothing I said wasn't true facts or at least in how I remember in past games. plus I was being passive aggressive but it probably came as more aggressive idk idc idk why he kept wanting me to label the post as townie or scummy. idk he didn't accept me saying how I didn't mean to add an extra not.

    seems like that be something to post about more so then my responses.

    why do you think Rad kept asking me the same question over and over? how would you have responded in a similar situation? do you think knowing now that it was a bit weird at least to me that he kept on it, that maybe it changes the way you view how I made long post to answer his question in full and gave that short post of his my complete full and undivided attention? that idk maybe it's why I said the things I said in the way I said them? that just because I call Rad out on stuff that it isn't neccesarily shade? and even if it was shade that it isn't neccesarily scummy?
    To clarify, the bold I highlighted in #64 can also be seen as passive-aggressive, which is inherently scummy. It doesn’t MEAN I see you as a scumread but moreso a person of interest for that response.

    Why would Rad repeat himself? I have no idea.

    What would I do? Once it has been said, it can always be quoted as reference.

    Rad keeping on the pressure could just be justified as making sure he keeps a tab on every player’s thought process. That’s as far as it goes.

  49. ISO #99
    Soul Reader DaisyCloud's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2017
    Posts
    1,620
    Community
    TvM Hub, FFS, SmirkNation
    Pronouns
    she/her/her/hers/herself
    Gender
    Quote Originally Posted by GhostCat (#96)
    Quote Originally Posted by DaisyCloud (#89)
    [spoiler]



    huh, okay originally I thought it was null the things DUDE said. but yeah it is a bit early to be making cases. and yeah retread it be weird to say no meta and then use meta.

    idk think your points is more valid the DUDE'S.

    I like your points and it seems more like town snooks. you are at 61/2 tho now. idk if that means anything to you.

    I look forward to more of your comments to things going on so far in game and look forward to your own say on things too.
    I’ve yes, been doing Mom things and will again for a bit soon. Also time for the almost regularly scheduled evening hailstorm. If I don’t post again in the next few hours, that may be why.

    But there are things to read now, though I’ve said what I’m most concerned about atm. Is there anyone else in specific you want me to comment on?

    Yeah, Rad’s pressing you on that wording about not NAI is town-Rad looking “behaviour” but it’s really kind of a weird thing to press someone on.

    Dude and Ninja doing substantial things. So far Dude wanted to talk about how many vanillas and PRs we have, and Ninja had the same kind of thoughts as I did about Silver’s post (as I was writing what turned out to be that wall.) I haven’t really made a “read” on them yet. But Idk that what they’ve done is “substantial”.

    And unless I missed it, Brandon and Alpha still haven’t chimed in on anything. I expect Pol and NASA to be in soon. So a third of the players aren’t even here yet. Stitch’s opening was kinda scummy, but eh...might have been waiting to see Rad’s response (and sleeping). He’ll have more to say soon.

    I expect to have a lot to read in the morning.
    time zones is a big factor. stitch is in India iirc. so idk that might of been his soon to be going to sleep time. he should be active again soon, in a few hours iirc? just as I'll be going to sleep. the window to chat with him be between 5am-10am USA PST. he could be on before that time or after but that is a good window.

    sf is in the UK and so is Kai/NASA

    idk about polarity or J1M nor Comet.

    Alpha, idk he is in USA too so is Brandon. they should have done been here by now. :/

  50. ISO #100
    Thread Analyst ImjustaDude's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2020
    Posts
    260
    Timezone
    UTC-05:00
    Community
    Smirk Nation
    AKA
    Dude
    Gender
    My vote stands for now until everyone posts.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  •  

Keyboard Shortcuts

about us
Mafia Universe is a community hub for people who enjoy playing the forum variant of Mafia (also known as Werewolf). We offer fully automated Mafia games and a wide variety of customized features crafted to optimize your game experience. We also proudly host the Internet's only database of Mafia/Werewolf communities.

We hope you stick around!
Role of the Day
Nexus

The Nexus will every night passively redirect the actions of all players that target it to a different randomly chosen player. Kills, however, will not be redirected.