The Musical is getting closer who is the music in you?
The Musical is getting closer who is the music in you?
As for Ryan, I mostly agree with you.
He said he would vote her on day 1 and then never did that very day. He voted her day 2 when she wasn't under pressure (first vote), then unvoted asa you got in. Sorry if this has already been discussed but I feel it's noticable.
I'm glad you're back sharpay. I like your world's posts but I disagree with them. I want to say Taylor is the most independently scummy but I don't want it to be seen as distancing so I'll explain some of the things I've done this game and why I'm town first
Also I'm mobile at work so it may not be the easiest to make, I'm also not as experienced with the formatting
responding to p#642
"The basic suspicion is that they both were detrimentals to d1 and d2 mislynches.
Martha being the second ML is only strenghtening the POE, since a N1 kill may have put too much light on them"
I understand my pushing the mislynches. It's not a good look but no one's voting record here is particularly good. I think you can learn that I'm town from how I've acted rather than vote logic. First thing I'll say is I don't actually think Taylor contributed much to the mislynches. My main argument against Taylor it's that they have had zero scum reads all game. They are just saying, imo, that town is town and asking questions. Second, I don't think Martha was someone I ever would have been scared of. She was barely active and her cases were weak. I had no problems arguing with Chad for half of yesterday and they were clearly a much stronger player. Chad eventually saw me as strongly town and I had the same read on them at the later end of the day. I also think considering all this I wouldn't kill Chad if I was mafia.
"That's Taylor's reply. Could be real, but ultimatly it's a take or reject argumentation."
I didn't think Martha's case was very strong and I wanted to kill a low poster to just narrow our odds. On reflection killing a non-active was probably not useful, as Chad explained, but that's what I thought was the best action day 1 and I didn't think this case was particularly strong so I didn't comment on it. I thought most the people Taylor town read we were all town reading as well for point one, and for point three he was specifically replying to me saying I've not played mountainous.
"Yeah, let's shade Gabriella too."
I don't see the problem with this. I was trying to figure out the best kill between the inactives and I wasn't sure about any of them. I think the exact opposite is why I scum read Taylor, for example. He argued a lot more confidently that x person was town though they were a low poster. I believe his thinking they are town is TMI. I had no clue what was between these four and so it was a difficult decision to make.
"On the buzzer elimination."
I don't like randoming. Gabriella's posts were bad but they weren't scummy particularly. They weren't solvey, they weren't scummy. So I didn't know about her. Martha on the other hand had tried to be solvey but her cases felt extremely bad. It sounded to me like she was trying to solve as wolf and just completely failed. So of course I'd rather kill her, there's no reason to leave it to rng. I also would have liked to discuss my vote before end of day and so hadn't changed it earlier, but not many people were around at end of day. My Gabriela vote also was made to get her to talk a bit more, which you can see at the time I posted my vote. I think if you read day 2 my vote will make sense but I get why it looks bad.
Amendment: people were around at end of day but the discussion wasn't about the lynch as much as it should have been. You weren't there and Chad didn't discuss the vote, the two of you who were my strongest town and people who's opinions I thought would be more useful. Gabriella and Martha both weren't there either, the people being voted. So it wasn't too useful for vote discussion
So that post was really long. Here's a summary. Taylor is constantly trying to contribute by town reading people no matter what. His reads make sense at the time but you can easily see very bad consistency. He tries to lightly push some town but immediately calls them town after. He never town reads Ryan past day 1 and his day 1 interactions with him are awkward. He is frequently trying to look like he's contributing by asking questions but they go no where and he doesn't follow up on them much
You two would be because (fmpov) Darbus has always pushed eliminations onto flipped townies, and you've been like "yes I agree" to almost all of Darbus's posts. If Darbus is w, you're their partner.
Now, unlike Zeke, I don't know the player behind Gabriela. I do not have much experience here, and therefore haven't played so many games yet. I have never recalled a player posting/acting the way Gabriela did/does, and that is why I did not know if Gabriela was a wild card.
ugh sorry. Mobile is annoying, it kept all my multi quote for some reason. But Ryan, that's a pretty weak defense
#379... which is thin. Can you help me?
The reason why I didn't want them gone afterwards was because of the fact that when Martha flipped v, my brain went "okay must have been a WIFOM kinda kill" in the sense that both players were v, but the wolves killed the person scum reading them both so that Martha and Gabriela would be thought of as w/w. I don't know if this logic even makes sense (or if people even use it, for that matter).
Ryan what is your most likely team
What do you think of Taylor
Once again I have done no reading, but I can tell you we're NLing today
I regret not switching to Gabriela. I had the time to and was actively considering it in the last couple of minutes but decided against it because I voted Martha to tie and thought that Darbus switching away from Gabriela could be not mafia motivated since Gabs/Darbus was on my anti-aligns list.
Not sure if we have maj or not so I'm not going to put a vote down.
Can you explain why I'm scum
But because of that I'd like an explanation of why you read Taylor that way
After rereading I find it pretty plausible for a team of you/Taylor.
You're reason for thinking I'm scummy is bad and the association you make with me to Taylor is much weaker than the association you two have
I put confidence in my reads, that's basically what you're accusing me of. But you did not vote them? You did. Did you defend them? No. Did you create a counter push so a townie doesn't get mislynched? No. You're just as much culpable as I am and it's your strongest point against me. I'll bring up Chad again that they also wanted to lead town and they led them exactly the same place I did yesterday. So if a strong, confirmed townie does this maybe you should try to find a little more. Mislynches are just going to be a part of mountainous.
Who do you think the team is?
You and Taylor, very strongly
What time is it? 4 hours left to play this day
Hey sharpay sorry
I get why you think it could be a world of us two but I think it's much more obviously Ryan and Taylor
Ok And if you die tonight I've enjoyed playing with you
Just to clarify, I did not add 30 minutes to this cycle, I started 30 minutes late thanks to work, so in total you had 48 hours.
Things like this remember me to that I need to say this things now or never.
Or I will have to scream