only my recent posts? i've been slacking
only my recent posts? i've been slacking
Esooa - #25 is probably just a joke and there's a decent chance it was created pre-rand so NAI. Overall seems like a pretty normal start for her, haven't seen enough of her to get a read on yet personally. Anger at neopest feels genuine, leaning away from w/w for the two. Overall null.
if you mean the reaction to the claim, bluekang felt reactive rather than demonstrative, i'd say. the reaction of taking a stand to look "protown" can be a scum thing. not guaranteed, but enough for early game. bluekang's posts since then are meh, not great.
does he?
i can tell you for a fact i would say exactly nothing about the claim as scum
you are very obviously trying to act productive, though? don't get this
I think we both know that's not what I meant. Trying to do things that end up genuinely being productive is fine and that's how I prefer to play ly D1s honestly (or at least get my reads sorted out in my head or else I feel lost).
Saying not to talk about a certain topic on the first page of a thread on D1 looks more like something scum does to appear to be productive for the fake of looking productive to others without actually contributing anything. Like, fair enough if you had a better topic of discussion to move onto... but you absolutely didn't. That's why I think you did it more to look good than any genuine reason.
##Vote Master Radishes
lmao
nah it's because i didn't want the discussion to be about his claim because i felt that was a bad approach, and the game moved away from that and things have been fine
That is most definitely not a spewed town situation
Why
Um
Because I don't think it's that important? I know it's a claim and all but I'd rather focus on other things.
Diffusion of Power Day 1 Votecount
Votes Target Voters (Posts in Phase) 1 Esooa Gira (15) 1 neopest Esooa (21) 1 BlueKang grimdog (19) 1 grimdog neopest (56) 1 Honey Transcend (43) 1 EllieD Wiml (17) 1 Master Radishes fwogcarf (31) 6 Not voting Honey (8), EllieD (3), BlueKang (15), Master Radishes (7), Eliphas (2), Wisdom (13)
View Vote History
Day 1 ends at 6:00 PM EST on Wednesday, February 24th, 2021. There are 1614207660000 remaining.
so here's a Q: why is ellie suspect for being consensus-y when eliphas's opinions were similarly repeating things other people had said?
idk if I've ever legitimately melded with Transcend and this was as close to how much I ever have so probably >>>>rand town imoEcho. Feels like subtle setting up not just towards you guys but other players on the board.
rn I'm thinking neopest is maybee town. Probably gonna be wary of them though all game
not just this post specifically but I like fwog's tone
I think she's reasonably towny
If those reads were consensus-y before Eliphas made them then that was a mistake on my part and I would agree that they look worse for it. For Ellie, I was comparing her reads directly to Eliphas' and I remembered the Transcend read from memory.
have you seen him wolf? lol
meh I disagree with this meta assessment but it's not a big dealThe one time I saw him wolf he was this silk smooth people pleasing solving little sneak. I then saw him town and he was hurrdurring like this quite a lot.
It's not a locked read but for what it is I believe it's quite towny.
why doe
neopest is jus here to beat up all derp clearers/lamist town (joke)I was kind of put off by their immediate attempt at derp clearing and it seemed like they tried to avoid reading a lot of the more controversial slots, but I do think some of their reads just come from rand > town so it’s actually not as bad as I stated at first
##Vote BlueKang
vote was stale, like this better right now, play seems "safe" overall
That's fair. From this and Gira's response to it, I probably won't factor it into my reads any more. It was mostly just a play I knew I would make as scum.
Doing my ISO of Transcend, I wonder if he would be a good cop target? While he is generally town read, clearing him would cause scum to have to kill a weaker role and give the stronger roles an extra night. Not sure if this is worth the opportunity cost of somebody harder to clear in general which is why I brought it up.
don't direct cop targets
I'm not telling people to check him, I'm genuinely asking if that is the right sort of philosophy for a cop check.
philosophy for a cop check is check someone in your nullreads
the thing is even openly suggesting him as a potential investigation makes him a worse investigation b/c then if he's town mafia have good reason to shoot him
Thanks.
Transcend - Agree that the early claim is pretty towny. Don't have anything in particular here that stands out to me but I think their overall tone and thought process seems towny to me and I mindmeld with a lot of it. Dog friend is a town lean for me.
I think the bolded comes from town tbh.
Diffusion of Power Day 1 Votecount
Votes Target Voters (Posts in Phase) 2 BlueKang grimdog (19), Gira (20) 1 neopest Esooa (30) 1 grimdog neopest (56) 1 Honey Transcend (43) 1 EllieD Wiml (24) 1 Master Radishes fwogcarf (31) 6 Not voting Honey (8), EllieD (3), BlueKang (15), Master Radishes (7), Eliphas (2), Wisdom (13)
View Vote History
Day 1 ends at 6:00 PM EST on Wednesday, February 24th, 2021. There are 1614207660000 remaining.
Posted at 1 days, 6 hours, 38 minutes, 58 seconds remaining.
If this is a serious opinion I'd like to discuss this post game.I don't expect people to know how to handle pr's to I told themnothing to do with being "right" and everything to do with it being a generic sort of statement that can be made to appear town
don't really scumread her other posts, though, but do not have a better place for my vote at this moment in time
how u handle them is not by claiming start of game
I felt that Esooa had a tangible reason for why she thought it was unnecessary and she went as far as to explain it so that others wouldn’t keep outing themselves.if you mean the reaction to the claim, bluekang felt reactive rather than demonstrative, i'd say. the reaction of taking a stand to look "protown" can be a scum thing. not guaranteed, but enough for early game. bluekang's posts since then are meh, not great.
Whereas BlueKang kind of just piled on with it and said it just to say it. I’ll also say that for a reactive post, it didn’t ping me as having any real emotion behind it. I think that’s NAI, but it also certainly doesn’t sound like BlueKang truly cared that he claimed or not.
I mean it's based on two or three ordinary games and Champs so it's not waterproof, but I'd still say it's good enough to base a read him on?meh I disagree with this meta assessment but it's not a big dealThe one time I saw him wolf he was this silk smooth people pleasing solving little sneak. I then saw him town and he was hurrdurring like this quite a lot.
It's not a locked read but for what it is I believe it's quite towny.
Do you guys want my opinion on Radishes' meta..?
I think I finally found something to read Esooa based on.
I don't think she'd push Neopest and be all in his face, only to end up with a town read on him, as wolf. I expect wolf!Esooa to push that into a wolf read.
Also Esooa/Neopest never w/w but meh
yes, at least 2000 words please
No but actually I do love talking about myself so I could. But I'm in my phone rn.
the thing is someone can have tangible reasons that are mechanically sound and still be scum but this is too far into the theoretical realm, i don't fos esooa anymoreI felt that Esooa had a tangible reason for why she thought it was unnecessary and she went as far as to explain it so that others wouldn’t keep outing themselves.if you mean the reaction to the claim, bluekang felt reactive rather than demonstrative, i'd say. the reaction of taking a stand to look "protown" can be a scum thing. not guaranteed, but enough for early game. bluekang's posts since then are meh, not great.
Whereas BlueKang kind of just piled on with it and said it just to say it. I’ll also say that for a reactive post, it didn’t ping me as having any real emotion behind it. I think that’s NAI, but it also certainly doesn’t sound like BlueKang truly cared that he claimed or not.
second point is ~fair enough
I exclusively use mobile for mafia.
Town:
Transcend
Wiml
Esooa
MR
Honey
neopest
Wolf:
The rest??
I don't have a read on this person, off with his head!
##Vote Eliphas
I'm currently null on you. Like I can tell your pushes aren't TOO serious and I understand why you're doing it to certain people like Honey upon her entrance into the game to try to get some sort of friction or to wake someone up and not be just a bulletin board of reads.I also thought the same, but what do you think about my alignment? This statement kinda bugs me because it's possible you're saying this to encourage him to keep thinking this way (which would be wrong).
I get the point Gira's making where you've gone for almost everyone that's been in the early going of the game. Could be a maf move to see which town chain breaks first.
Again, null read, I'm giving time for my reads to fully form.
the meta i have on transcend is the last game i was pr with him he found someone completely ingenuine early, pushed on them w complete confidence and then pulled everyone else on board he was way more focused than he's shown this game to me and he's not being up front about his motivations for playing this way. he tries to frame everyone's actions and thoughts as w malicious intent (see above) except for ellie?? which i found really strange too
when i hadnt even started posting yet o__o
ah valid. yeah i like to get the game started quickly, but i wouldn't say this is an alignment tell for me (:Hi! o/
I don't remember seeing you wolf outside mashes, but I expect you to be more sneaky that blatantly claim to end rvs. Iirc you did something similar in the game where I tunneled you real bad but you flipped v.
what is an alignment tell for you?
Posting Permissions
Keyboard Shortcuts
Originally Posted by neopest
Quote
