: Amrock and I were arguing extensively in our chat about who should sheep the other. Of course by this I mean amrock wanted to trust my read and I wanted to trust his heh. Think we confirmation biased ourselves into some possibly good reads after awhile XD
Bread & Butter:
Wanted to sheep amrock's early take on the sulit slot and I think chloe has been excessively villagery. Think just the way chloe went at amrock for having a townread on her slot that she felt was unjustified was super towny especially with how hard she went at it.
Had this slot low and then they skyrocketed as they continued to post. Amrock said he was leaning town on hk slot and I trust that take since amrock has good read there and I just think a lot of their snaps at people have been sassy in a way I think is generally villagery: see 657 682
Think the continuation of the conversation with jc where he goes over his takes on swedish and ara are just... very good takes I think? 694 714 887
. Presentation wise just calmly explaining why they have swedish as more likely scum in the face of scrutiny just seems like more towny than not, and he freeflow talks about a lot of slots in a way that reads genuine after early game (which was where I thought their takes were more easy and not getting out there in villagery way).
Mehhh so despite how high I have this read I have a lot of grievances namely I get the impression most of his wolves are pretty likely town and think he's starting from places of lock confidence in his reads which doesn't tend to click well with my brain.
The reason I have him this strongly into my town is I've seen him wolf and town a lot lately and have consistently called him the correct alignment. This game he feels like a tryhard loose cannon which is the vibe I tend to get from him when he's town and he's had a lot of interactions and posts justifying his thread stances that have just the classic jc vibe.
A lot of the time when he's a wolf I just end up really not caring much about anything he's doing which isn't really the case here. This description is bad but I meta read him on impression on his overarching play rather than from specifics.
Kaito and Kokichi:
Sad this slot has us scum since I enjoy their gimmick so much but think they've had a generally villagery thread presence and a few times I remember having their thought process be one I assosicate with town or think mysellf like them saying someone is townier for pushing on townreads of themsef which is a thought process I use often myself to find town.
Think Hornet's reaction to the jc sus was something I'd expect from hornet regardless of alignment since they tend to take things seriously and think some of their posts outside the initial spat with jc feel intuitive and like they're considering the alignments and motivations of the different reads they talk about.
Motly an amrock sheep having em above null since I'm not entirely sold but he thiks they're towny and I trust his takes. I think I pushed ara for towwnreading me last time we played so I think them calling amrock half town and me wolf is a cheeky comment on how not to get me to wolfread them haha.
Think they have had a lot of good evaluative posts I've liked which earned them their own tier for me.
Flipped a coin and am hard aligning with them indefinetely. AMrock mentioned them being sus for some of their stances but their posts so far have thoroughly entertained me in a good way. "but limestone being entertained isn't ai!!?!?!?!!!!". For me I tend to click a lot more with the types of thoughts town have so yes me enjoying people tends to point them a bit villagery. I think some of their posts had solvey nature as well.
Popped in voted go rams, I'm calling em a legend villager and leaving it at that. Issss what I wanted to say but chickened out and now they're backin null. Don't actually have a sus on gorams and have a full list I'm sure we'll get explained later when they have more time. Vaguely mention talks with other head and offthread solving and how I process this will be pending.
I sorta liked some of their posting but moved em down cause don't feel particularly strongly about anything they've said based on any logic and the gut feeling is also weak. gth town.
Read his posts up to 926 which is the most recent as I make this read. Nothing especially ai here, possibly villagery suspision since it fits in with low effort villagers looking for the motivations of stuff but not moving his place in the list because this is speculative and not strong. (know the push is wrong and on amrock for reading into humor, don't care)
Ended up moving this read down a few times just cause their reads come off very isoalted to me in the sense there's not a lot of flow to them and it feels a lot more postur-y and stuff, at least to me. As similar to all reads here this impression is not strong enough to move out of null.
Lip Bite Phoenix:
Their entire iso gave me litterally 0 impressions one way or the other. Tends to be rand mafia when this happens so keeping them on the lower side of my null. They've been pretty active for how little their posts leave a lasting impression heh.
Most crappy read here but both punchy and mac hate wolfing and get invested fast as town so their slot being left as low poster I think is just slightly higher than rand to be wolf. This is kind of extended by one of the heads showing up and giving two reads and some fluff while here. Lot's of explanations like time zones being busy at start of day ect, wouldn't push them for this but would have them as a better guess for wolf on this if that makes sense.
Never played with either of these people however we did collect a decent chuck of their meta and think so far they don't seem like the obvious town slot they can be and have had a few moments of their mindset that don't align with what we expected of their play from the limited meta gathered. Amrock felt they were more likely wolf and none of their posts particularly stood out to me so have em low myself.
The Weird Taste Walrus:
This one is amrock's strong wolfread and I have em quite low myself. I think both logic and knights are people who tend to just exsude villagery thought process when town and considering both heads were around and generally contributing but neither made a splash with me was pretty worrying. Played with knights recently and he was one of the towniest posters early and then I foiled him late while here he mentioned our experiences but didn't do the same gamesolvey stuff he did before. Logic half amrock has strong scum read from and also didn't do much for me on readthrough.