
Originally Posted by
Hyena
1674604201
(
#815)

Originally Posted by
staypositivefriend
1674603156
(
#774)
wrt to my selections, my ultimate goal is to help create a pool of potential eliminations that contains as many mafia as possible. i perceive the best way to do this to be to nominate as many confident townreads to my committee as possible. i don't like the strategy of nominating people that i only Kind Of townread and i think it is suboptimal
@
staypositivefriend
I just had a thought. I'm just gonna toss this idea out there:
CiderHead
Go look at his ISO, tell me what you think in terms of, like, his interactions (or lack of insightful interactions), and come back and tell me if you think it would be a good idea making him a judge if we're trying to go for people who are probably town.
honestly i haven't talked about it yet because i wanted to give him time, but ciderhead is actually one of my wolfreads
i was pinged by him saying that he thought raj was trying to force herself into the towncore (P440) when pretty much every post he has made since reads like a player who is trying very hard to push himself into the towncore
the reason i feel this way is because ciderhead has basically reiterated how much he agrees with the consensus multiple times, and he has also broadly agreed with all the players being townread (p
#446), but he doesn't seem to have many unique thoughts about any individual players
the problem for me isn't that ciderhead agrees with the consensus, it's more that ciderhead coming into the game and going: "yeah i think every single player being townread is actually probably town" and then just not really talking about it further reads to me like a player who is not really scumhunting or putting honest thought in the game
i think he might be developing reads too quickly and too confidently because he is a wolf who is burdened with TMI
i was gonna let this read simmer for a bit before i posted it, but that's where im at with cider rn